news
UGC announces NET exemption cut-off date for MPhil holders
09 Nov 2010

University Grants Commission (UGC) has decided to exempt all candidates who obtained an MPhil degree on or before July 10, 2009 from clearing the National Eligibility Test (NET) to qualify for a lecturer’s job.

The decision, taken at the UGC's 472nd meeting recently, comes as a huge relief for MPhil degree holders. The UGC had last year said that for the post of assistant professor it is mandatory to qualify NET. This regulation had invited strong protests from a cross-section of the academic community and also led to multiple litigations in various high courts, including the Madras high court.

At its meeting, the UGC noted that the UGC Regulations of 2009/2010 "are prospective and not retrospective in nature," and therefore resolved that "all candidates having MPhil degree on or before July 10, 2009 shall remain exempted from the requirement of NET for the purpose of appointment as lecturer/assistant professor."

A copy of the minutes of the meeting furnished to a Delhi-based applicant under the Right to Information Act revealed that similar exemption shall be applicable to all candidates who have obtained a PhD degree on or before December 31, 2009. Candidates, who had registered themselves for PhD degree on or before July 10, 2009 and are subsequently awarded PhD degree, shall also enjoy the exemption from NET. The new exemption might just fill various vacancies in universities across the country that is facing serious faculty crunch.

[Source: Times of India]

Exclusive Feature on UGC-NET Exemption by our correspondent - "Impact of UGC Regulation exempting NET for MPhil. holders"

Comments

Your comment will be published after moderation.
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd><p>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.
Connect
Sign in using Facebook
NAMRATA SINGH
10 Oct 2014

I was registered for Ph. d degree in Pt. Ravishankar shukla University, Raipur, on 14 september 2009 without written entrance test and finally awarded on 14 february 2013. What is the solution for candidates like us who are reigstred after the deadline of UGC july 2009 and without entrance test??????

Dr L Bijen Meitei
27 Sep 2014

Inhuman laws, regulations and rules may not have merits, may regulations be sensible, it is eligibility, not selection. Let us not limit the ability of aspirants. Getting Ph.D. is not easy as we think. The amendment of U.G.C is very sensible.

sap traing in chennai
23 Sep 2014

best institute in chennai

Sqn.Ldr.(Dr.). J.P. Singh
27 Aug 2014

The quality of education has deteriorated to the lowest level due to inability of regulatory bodies in monitoring the quality and performance. We have privatised the education system on PPP basis, which has become a business with enormous profit. Today educated unemployed are more than uneducated unemployed. This is high time that we make stringent check and take stern action against defaulters.

rakesh
08 Aug 2014

UGC NET cleared with Fake SC papers..what action is initiated against the guilty.
It takes minimum 15 yrs in high court to declare a guilty as guilty in India due to lack of interest to take up fake SC cases seriously. If an employee is suspended, then the series of writ petitions run for 15yrs. Suspended employee sits idle at home for 15yrs to claim 15 yrs salary as lumpsum. Who is responsible for such treatment? All fake SC papers job holders are treated as ' A king's new clothes' by their family members, relatives and neighbors. The defense lawyer tries to justify the need to fool the courts & country for money. If that lawyer fails to get positive response from family members& relatives, then that lawyer mobilises local police to torture them with some petty issues. We learnt that some honest Police gets injured or succumbed to firing carried out by fake currency gang in Hyderabad. Can we treat - Contempt of court orders by HC against IAS officers (who want to curb the menace of fake SC job holders) can be seen as firing done by fake certificate gang. Please refer to AP High court CC201/2012 and CC1023/2013 orders issued for re-appointment and disbursement of salary to a fake SC papers job holder smt Biruda Raja Ratnam, lecturer, ASP Oriental College, Ram Kothi, Hyderabad. Plz refer Refer AP High Court WP 34222/2011. Who can do justice to real Scheduled Caste people? we have many Anushka Agarwals in India who get all favors at their door step that includes fake SC papers, UGCNET papers, Ph.D thesis and many more. Who can check them?

Balaji Poul
14 Jul 2014

I am assistant Professor in Modern college Bombay. My first appointment is dated on 19.12.2001 at that time I was MPhil degree holder. My question is on wihc date I will get Senior scale under CAS

swatantra kumar pal
26 Mar 2014

Ye deegri vailid hai

DATTA
03 Mar 2014

Please give me clear status on M Phil case in supreme court .which is the result date of M Phil case ?M Phil before 10 july2009 is exempted from NET

Ankit Rawat
20 Feb 2014

My friend passed CTET in his first attempt because he take coaching classes from widyalaya that is awesome coaching center.

DATTA
04 Feb 2014

Please give me clear status on M Phil case in supreme court .which is the result date of M Phil case ?M Phil before 10 july2009 is exempted from NET

Dr. Vijay Kumar Thapa
23 Jan 2014

Respected Sir I completed my P.hd. in Dec.1993.Am I exempt from UGC/NET ?

DATTA
01 Jan 2014

Please give me clear status on M Phil case in supreme court .which is the result date of M Phil case ?

DATTA
20 Dec 2013

which is the result date?

mishra
17 Dec 2013

next hearing date is 30/12/2013.

DATTA
10 Dec 2013

In supreme court which is next hearing date? which is the result date?

Dr D.Kalaiselvan
06 Dec 2013

Respected sir
I want to know about from which date distance mode mphil are not elegible in tamilnadu for the post of asst.prof.in govt arts colleges.
Please forward to me. by my mail.

m.kohila
06 Dec 2013

sir/madam

i completed mphil in the year 2005 from madurai kamaraj university by distance education system . the mphil is eligible or not

Dr.D.Kalaiselvan
06 Dec 2013

sir
i completed mphil in the year 1998 from madurai kamaraj university by distance education system . i completed NET in june 2011and copleted phd 2012.
you shall be notified date from when the mphil programme are not eligible at distance education

Dr.D.Kalaiselvan
06 Dec 2013

sir you shall be notified date from when the mphil programme are not eligible at distance education

k.sudha
03 Dec 2013

Dear sir/madam I am M.E (power electronics &drives) degree holder. i am planned to do my phd in wind energy but i dont know how to start ,where to start,what to do. so please give some steps to carry out my work

pushpender dahiya
03 Dec 2013

next hearing date is 10/12/2013

DATTA
30 Nov 2013

which is supreme court next hearing date?

DATTA
18 Nov 2013

Hi, , I am working as a Teaching Assistant in a degree college from last 10 years.I have completed my MPHIL in june 2007 in mathematics. Whether UGC exempted mphil holders before july 10 2009 or not? if not, why ugc is playing game with us? Please reply me soon.

DATTA
18 Nov 2013

UTTARAKHAND OPEN UNIVERSITY
Corrigendum (Appointments of Professors/ Asstt. Professors )
UOU/R/Ad./2010

In advertisement no. UOU/R/Ad./2010, dated 13.12.2010, the following change in academic qualification for the post of Assistant Professor is made in accordance with UGC guide-lines.

“Candidates who have completed M.Phil. Degree on or before 10th July, 2009 and have obtained Ph.D. degree on or before 31st December, 2009 or had registered themselves for Ph.D. degree on or before 10th July, 2009 and are subsequently awarded Ph.D. degree, shall remain exempted from the requirement of NET”.

Further, the last date of submission of application for all Posts is therefore
extended upto 29th January, 2011.

Registrar
application/pdf iconcorrigendum_14012010.pdf

2011
careers

DATTA
13 Nov 2013

Give me clear status on MPhil. It is eligible or not for Asst.Prof .
If Assam govt. and Uttarakhand Open University had issued notification to exempt m. phil before 11 july 2009 from NET.
Why not other Universities.

Ashish Deshmukh
05 Nov 2013

M.Phil and Ph.D. in distance mode after 2009 are not valid.But candidate registered before 2009 and obtained such degree after 2009 are valid.Also UGC NET Pattern is change from JUNE 2014.

DATTA
25 Oct 2013

National Eligibility Test
RELATED KEYWORDS:

Higher Education
Ugc
Aspirants
Nagpur University
Subject
| More

Popular Articles About National Eligibility Test
NEWS
UGC's final qualifying criteria for NET gets apex court nod
September 22, 2013 | Vishwas Kothari , TNN
PUNE: The Supreme Court has upheld the University Grants Commission's (UGC) final qualifying criteria policy prior to declaring results of the National Eligibility Test (NET), which was held in June 2012. The NET is the qualifying exam for eligibility to junior research fellowship (JRF) and lectureship in Indian universities and colleges. "We are of the view that, in academic matters, unless there is a clear violation of statutory provisions, the regulations or the...
National Eligibility Test Articles By Date
INDIA
Yogendra Yadav ouster looms over UGC meet
October 2, 2013 | Akshaya Mukul , TNN
NEW DELHI: The shadow of political scientist Yogendra Yadav dominated the full meeting of the UGC on Tuesday as the Commission asserted itself and told members that contrarian view would not be part of the minutes of the meeting. UGC officials also told members not to talk to media and said only the chairperson and the secretary is authorized to speak on behalf of the Commission. The meeting cleared some of the routine matters related to research funding and grants to be given out during...
NEWS
University Grants Commission releases National Eligibility Test cut-off marks
April 5, 2013 | TNN
ALLAHABAD: The authorities of the University Grants Commission (UGC) have released the much-awaited cut-off marks for various subjects under National Eligibility Test (NET) which was conducted in December. The cut-off for different categories has been prepared on the basis of the aggregate of all three papers for which the exam was conducted by the UGC. In December 12, a total of 28824 candidates had applied for NET (Dec 12) while 23445 had finally appeared in...
CHANDIGARH
National Eligibility Test gains for 938 students of Chandigarh
March 27, 2013 | TNN
CHANDIGARH: As results of the National Eligibility Test (NET), conducted by the University Grants Commission (UGC), were announced on Tuesday, a wave of cheer spread across the city. Several students cracked the exam in subjects like computer science, English and law, in which students have generally been faring poorly. Nearly 4.69% of students who appeared in the NET exam conducted in December 2012, from Panjab University managed to clear it. The exam is a gateway to...
GOA
Goa among seven states to not hold own Teacher Eligibility Test
October 1, 2013 | TNN
PANAJI: Goa is one among seven of the 35 states and union territories across India that have not conducted an independent Teacher Eligibility Test (TET) for its school teachers. The TET has been recommended by the central government Right of Child to Free and Compulsory Education (RTE) Act, 2009. The TET has been made mandatory for teachers who have a diploma in education, but is not necessary for teachers who possess a degree in education. Based on the RTE act's...
NEWS
Tamil Nadu announces special TET for differently-abled BEd teachers
October 1, 2013 | PTI
CHENNAI: Tamil Nadu government on Monday said it would conduct a special Teachers Eligibility Test (TET) for differently-abled unemployed candidates with BEd degrees. The state teachers Recruitment Board would conduct the test. "Those differently-abled candidates with BEd, who clear TET would be employed in the backlog vacancies and in vacancies, which would arise in the future," chief minister Jayalalithaa said in a statement. The school education...
HYDERABAD
Hyderabad students to challenge new National Eligibility Test guidelines
December 31, 2012 | TNN
HYDERABAD: Students are planning to challenge UGC's new National Eligibility Test (NET) guidelines for lecturer posts. University Grants Commission (UGC) recently introduced a new rule stating that only top 15% candidates in NET will be eligible for taking up teaching jobs in colleges and universities. Till last year, any candidate who scored minimum marks was eligible for teaching posts. Students from English and Foreign Languages University (Eflu) on Sunday...
KANPUR
2 examinees caught cheating in National Eligibility Test
December 31, 2012 | TNN
KANPUR: The National Eligibility Test (NET) was held on Sunday at various centres in the city. There were seven centres in Chhatrapati Shahuji Maharaj University, a centre each at VSSD College in Nawabganj, Jai Narayan Vidya Mandir in Vikas Nagar and Nandlal Khanna Inter College, Ashok Nagar. Two students from VSSD College and one from Kanpur University centre were caught cheating in the examination. They were booked by the invigilators and debarred from further...
INDORE
National Eligibility Test online application submission date extended
May 1, 2012 | TNN
INDORE: In a major respite to aspirants facing problems in submitting online application form for National Eligibility Test (NET), the University Grants Commission has extended the last date for filing online application to May 2. The students were facing technical problems in submitting the form online and the last date for it was Monday. On the last day, Devi Ahilya Vishwavidhyalaya (DAVV) officials received many complaints from the worried students saying that...
INDORE
Less number of students from Devi Ahilya Vishwavidyalaya clear National Eligibility Test this year
April 4, 2013 | Ashish Gaur , TNN
INDORE: Less number of students of Devi Ahilya Vishwavidyalaya (DAVV) got selected in the National Eligibility Test (NET) this year, the results of which were declared recently. While 324 students cleared the exam last year, only 266 could crack the examination to start taking the noble profession of teaching. Out of total 266, a total of 249 university students got selected for lectureship while 17 qualified for Junior Research...
RAJKOT
4,198 candidates to appear for National Eligibility Test on Sunday
June 28, 2013 | TNN
RAJKOT: A total of 4,198 candidates from across the state will appear for National Eligibility Test (NET) conducted by University Grants Commission (UGC) on Sunday. Saurashtra University (SU) is the co-coordinating university for the examination. Dean, faculty of sciences at the university, Dr Girish Bhimani said out of 4,198 candidates, 2,360 are male, while 1,838 are female candidates. The NET examination would be held for 40 subjects, including...
NEWS
High court: No illegality in eligibility test results declared by UGC and Bharathiyar University
September 25, 2013 | TNN
CHENNAI: More than 250 aspiring lecturers lost a crucial round of litigation on Monday, when the Madras high court ruled that there was no illegality in the manner in which the UGC and Bharathiyar University declared National Eligibility Test (NET) and State-level Eligibility Test (SLET) results respectively. Justice KK Sasidharan, applying the September 19 ruling of the Supreme Court on a similar matter, said, "Since the legality and...
NEWS
UGC's final qualifying criteria for NET gets apex court nod
September 22, 2013 | Vishwas Kothari , TNN
PUNE: The Supreme Court has upheld the University Grants Commission's (UGC) final qualifying criteria policy prior to declaring results of the National Eligibility Test (NET), which was held in June 2012. The NET is the qualifying exam for eligibility to junior research fellowship (JRF) and lectureship in Indian universities and colleges. "We are of the view that, in academic matters, unless there is a clear violation of statutory provisions, the regulations or...
NEWS
Karnatak University will give NET training to students
September 14, 2013 | Srinivas Reddy , TNN
HUBLI: Karnatak University, Dharwad has set up an equal opportunity cell on its campus to train PG students for the National Eligibility Test conducted by the University Grants Commission. This was done in the wake of low pass percentage of candidates in NET examination and KUD decided to utilize its expertise to prepare students for the exam. NET is held twice a year, in June and December, but many students find it difficult. The cell will train...
NEWS
UGC-NET exam rescheduled for September 8
August 20, 2013 | IANS
NEW DELHI: The University Grants Commission (UGC) would again conduct the national eligibility test (NET) on September 8 for students of Delhi and Ranchi who could not appear when it was originally held on June 30, an official statement said on Monday. A re-examination is being done for the Delhi students who could not appear for the test as there was disturbance at the Kirori Mal College centre in June. "UGC is going to conduct the UGC-NET again for junior research...
NEWS
IGNOU invites applications for research programmes
July 28, 2013 | IANS
NEW DELHI: The Indira Gandhi National Open University (IGNOU) has invited applications for admission to research degree programmes in various disciplines, said a varsity statement on Sunday. "A candidate seeking registration in the research degree programmes (MPhil/PhD) for January 2014 cycle must hold a master's degree in the relevant discipline with minimum 55 per cent marks," the statement said. An entrance examination would be conducted on all-India basis and candidates who...
NAGPUR
High court's last chance for University Grants Commission to name National Eligibility Test criteria
January 8, 2013 | Vaibhav Ganjapure , TNN
NAGPUR: The University Grants Commission (UGC) on Monday came under fire from the Nagpur bench of Mumbai high court for its failure to come clear on the issue of fixing eligibility criteria for the National Eligibility Test (NET). A division bench comprising justices AP Lavande and Arun Chaudhari granted two weeks to the apex education body as the final chance to decide its policy. The judges further warned that it will proceed with orders,...
CHENNAI
UGC sets new NET exemption cut-off date for MPhil holders
November 9, 2010 | D Suresh Kumar , TNN
CHENNAI: In a major relief to thousands of MPhil degree holders aspiring for a lecturer's job, the University Grants Commission (UGC) has decided to exempt all candidates who obtained an MPhil degree on or before July 10, 2009 from clearing the tough-to-crack National Eligibility Test (NET) to qualify for appointment as a teacher in a college or university. The decision, taken at the UGC's 472nd meeting recently, comes as a huge relief for...
More Popular Articles about National Eligibility Test:1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next
MADURAI
Teaching aspirants made to wait for more than a day
July 27, 2013 | R Gokul , TNN
TRICHY : The ordeal of the teaching aspirants who had congregated at the office of the Regional Joint Director of Collegiate Education ( RJDCE ) in Trichy on Thursday to get experience certificates continued through the night. Many received the certificate only by Friday evening as officials at RJDCE struggled to complete the verification process and provide the due certificate to the applicants. At least, the would-be-teachers blamed the mess on the absence of clear...
ALLAHABAD
NET held at 40 centres in city
July 1, 2013 | TNN
ALLAHABAD : The National Eligibility Test (NET), conducted by the University Grants Commission ( UGC ), passed off peacefully at 40 centres in the city on Sunday. While 16 centres were situated on Allahabad University campus, rest were spread across different colleges and schools. Coordinator UGC, NET, Prof Mata Amber Tiwari said candidates braved rains to appear in the test that passed off peacefully. "We have got support from the police, fellow faculty members and...
More National Eligibility Test Articles by Date:1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next
THE TIMES OF INDIA
© 2013 Bennett, Coleman & Co. Ltd. All rights reserved
Index by Keyword
|
Index by Date
www.timesofindia.com
Feedback
|
Privacy Policy
|
Terms of Use
|
Advertise with us

DATTA
05 Oct 2013

Give me clear status on MPhil. It is eligible or not for Asst.Prof .
If Assam govt. and Uttarakhand Open University had issued notification to exempt m. phil before 11 july 2009 from NET.
Why not other Universities.

RAVI
28 Sep 2013

supreme court hearing 1 dec 2013

sarankumar
28 Sep 2013

UGC announced PhD is the qualification for Asst.Prof. then why the central universities recruitment's based on only NET qualification whether its contract or regular postings

give me clear status on MPhil. It is eligible or not.

DATTA
25 Sep 2013

What is the result of 24/09/2013 supreme court hearing on M Phil cutoff date? any idea

RAJA RATNAM
24 Sep 2013

FAKE ENCOUNTER WITH FACTS...http://www.apcce.gov.in/Documentation/June2013/Raja%20Ratnam.pdf

DATTA
23 Sep 2013

Assam govt. had issued notification after the judgement of assam high court to exempt m. phil before 11 july 2009 from NET.

DATTA
23 Sep 2013

Uttarakhand Open University
Corrigendum (Appointments of Professors/ Asstt. Professors )
Start: 00
UOU/R/Ad./2010
In advertisement no. UOU/R/Ad./2010, dated 13.12.2010, the following change in academic qualification for the post of Assistant Professor is made in accordance with UGC guide-lines.
“Candidates who have completed M.Phil. Degree on or before 10th July, 2009 and have obtained Ph.D. degree on or before 31st December, 2009 or had registered themselves for Ph.D. degree on or before 10th July, 2009 and are subsequently awarded Ph.D. degree, shall remain exempted from the requirement of NET”.
Further, the last date of submission of application for all Posts is therefore
extended upto 29th January, 2011.
Registrar
corrigendum_14012010.pdf
slp civil 36032 year 2010
why not other staste implimate this gr?
any idea

Ravi
20 Sep 2013

Next listing date 24/09/2013 for M.phil

DATTA
19 Sep 2013

What is the result of 17/09/2013 supreme court hearing on M Phil cutoff date? any idea

pushpender dahiya
10 Sep 2013

next hearing 17.09.2013

DATTA
10 Sep 2013

What is the result of 06/09/2013 supreme court hearing on M Phil cutoff date? any idea

Naveen
30 Aug 2013

Great relief for whose you completed the MPhil before july 10,2009. But this NET will be helpful to increase and improve the education quality and standard in India.

Naveen
dot net training in chennai

Anil sharma
28 Aug 2013

I submited my Ph.D in 2008 is it eligible fo rlecturer

rupa
23 Aug 2013

mphil done through distance mode in june 2008 is eligible for lecture post.do they need NET.

pushpender
21 Aug 2013

Date of Listing - 06/09/2013

DATTA
20 Aug 2013

What happened to 14/08/3013 supreme court hearing on M Phil cutoff date? any idea

DATTA
19 Aug 2013

I want to know are the MPhil holders before JULY 2009 are exempted from net/set

pathan kashim harun
16 Aug 2013

i want to know are the MPhil holders before 30th june 2009 are exempted from net/set

DR RAJASRI CHAKRABORTY(BANDYOPADYAY)
09 Aug 2013

Sir, I had completed my M.Phil(Env Sc),1992 though the exam was held in 1995. I had completed my Ph.D(Zoology) in 2001 & my age is 47. I have publications in both international & national journals till 2011.Kindly suggest me about my future position in job & whether I can attend refresher course for my accademic upliftment.

Jaideep Chatterjee
01 Aug 2013

SIR,
The chances of inclusion and preference of undeserving could not be ignored too easily to establish and cater the decision duly taken by U.G.C.............

Tom John
10 Jul 2013

HELLO TO THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
THE GREAT POWERFUL PROPHET THAT HELP
ME SOLVED MY PROBLEM IN THE SUPREME COURT.

I want to say thank you Prophet Ahmed i have won the case.
I'm Mr Tom from United State i was having problem in the court i was

thinking what to do,really it was a terrible problem in the court when

some one came from no were wanted to clam my company, he forged the

company paper and said the company belong to his late dad, then i was

so confused i didn't know what to do, on Sunday night i saw a Testimony

on internet how this prophet help one woman before i contact the

prophet and explain every thing to him, he told me not to worry since i

have contact him my problem is solved, he list some items for me and he

said i should buy them and send them to him to start the work for me

immediately i told him i can't buy the items here in united state and

he told me to send down the money so that he can buy the items there

and i do, he start the work before 3 days he told me he has finished

the work,he said i should not worry next time we are going to Court i

will see what will happen that i will see the result of his work really

on the court day i went to court the Judge declare to every body court

that i'm the owner of the company that is how i won the case, i'm so

happy now any body that see this comment should help me thank Prophet

Ahmed,before i forget in case any body have any problems free free and

contact him because his capable of handle any problems,he can also

release person in jail, his email solutiontemple39@gmail.com or cell

number +2347053375151.
prophet thank you so much i promise to share this Testimony to every

body in the world wide.

Jaideep Chatterjee
05 Jul 2013

This is amazing to note that exeptions are provided to whom did not allowed earlier.Many nodal agencies and policy making body have done nothing for the genuine development of educations rather majority of them are engaged in how to manufacture the brigade of hefty amount of salary holder with out educating but through the fulfilment of papers and certificates,those often been regalarised and demanded from such authorities,FOR EAMPLE: A.I.C.T.E. APPROVED FULL TIME P.G. DIPLOMA AS EQUIVALENT AS ANY POST GRADUATE DEGREE,ELIGIBLE TO APPEAR IN P.HD. PROGRAM,BUT U.G.C. yet to compile the same .............this is the feature of our educational body and fate of actual aspirants are under the clutches of such a haphazardial process....

SHIVAKUMAR.S.H
02 Jul 2013

I completed Mphil in july 2009 have i apply for degrre college librarian post sir,may i qulify Mphil degree in july 2009 is eligible or not

R.saravanan
29 Jun 2013

Sir,

I'm R.saravanan i had completed B.com, M.com & M.phil ( Commerce ) in distance education And i taking tution for School & College students. past 5 years i had tried to get the lecturer / Professor jobs in some private colleges, that principal said to me. you are not eligible for this job, because any degree should be completed in regular. so. i can't become as lecturer / professor . my ambission is broken. i need a full details. am i eligible or not. Please sent me to mymail id rsgayusaravana@gmail.com

Chandra Prakash Singh
23 Jun 2013

dear sir,
I have M.Phil. degree pass out on date june 2011. will I need to do cource work for Ph.D. degree.

Narender Kumar Chauhan
08 Jun 2013

I am NET qualified candidate and did my M.Phil from Alagappa University, Tamilnadu, in 2009. However, i wish to know one thing, 'is course work is exempted for me or not as having both NET and M.Phil in the same field'. An raly reply is being awaited in this connection. Thanks & regards
Academically yours

Narender Kumar Chauahn
cell:09896012653

Nirmali Borah
23 May 2013

i am a M Phil holder of Dec 2009 (Gauhati University, Assam). now I am working as a non sanction asst. prof in a college since Aug 2008. Is there any chance of extension of the cut off date of M Phil to exempt from Net/Set

seema dutta
17 May 2013

hi, i m seema from jharkhand (general category). i have completed my PG wth english but i got only 54%. i want to get a job as a lecturer. can anyone tell me pls if there is no university which can offer me courses of M.phil or P.hd with a percentage of 54 only in MA.
pls suggest.

rupa
04 May 2013

what contribution we can give for the case

pushpender dahiya
29 Apr 2013

Parties may file additional documents and complete the
final disposal on 14th August, 2013.

Ajmal
14 Apr 2013

What happened to 8/4/2013 supreme court hearing on MPhil cutoff date? any idea

Umamageshwari
09 Apr 2013

Hi I am from Chennai and currently I am doing my MBA in HRM thru distance education in Pondicherry University and I have plan to do M.Phil in future but I need to know if I do PG and M.Phil both in distance education can I able to get Lecturer job , is it taken as qualified.... Plz reply me

Ajmal
09 Apr 2013

What happened to 8/4/3013 supreme court hearing on MPhil cutoff date? any idea

Ritu
02 Apr 2013

Hi, I have done M.phil. i have applied for lecturer job few months befor. i got shortlisted for interview. After taken my interview they told me that we need M.phil+ UGC Net cleared guys for this post. At that time i felt frustate about their behaviour. I dont know why they didn't cleared that is UGC Net must be cleared or not.
Please let me know because i always finding this problem. i wanted to know that what is the requirement for a Assistant Professor.
Thanks n Regards,

Navodita Priyadarshani
19 Mar 2013

It's a gud move , net is the one of the thoughest exam in field of education ,so one who qualified it must be treated on priority for jobs as assistant professors.. First we will get our choices than a phd or m.phill should get it to fill the ample vacancies .. Phd is necessity for associate prof an professor jobs ..

manisha mhaske
18 Mar 2013

i completed mphil in 2009 have i exempted from net/set

mvassu
18 Mar 2013

what about the discussion on 15 march 2013 in regards of mphil relax june 2009 please

Ravi
11 Mar 2013

m.phil case in sprime court Next Date of Listing 08/04/2013.

manisha mhaske
05 Mar 2013

I completed m.phil in the june2009 and duing ph.d in concerned subject have I exempted net/set

Ravi
25 Feb 2013

m.phil case in SUPRIME COURT Next Date of Listing 15/03/2013 .

Ajmal
25 Feb 2013

what happened about today's hearing on Mphil cut off date

Harini
12 Feb 2013

But the real news is that the MHRD has declined to ratify this 472nd meeting of UGC. The MHRD has confirmed the same in several Courts in India and the final word is pending from Supreme Court that may be hearing the appeal by 25th of this month.

Laly.M.R
03 Feb 2013

I completed M.A M.Ed from kerala University I have awarded M.Phil Degree on December 1999. Now I am working as H.S.S.T Malayalam Aided school . I humbly request you to tell me is it qualified to post for a job in collage I am 46 years.

Uday Mahajan
01 Feb 2013

University Grants Commission (UGC) has decided to exempt all candidates who obtained an MPhil degree on or before July 10, 2009 from clearing the National Eligibility Test (NET) to qualify for a lecturer’s job. It is well and good. But when it will be implemented as no gazette notification ( or GR) from UGC or UNIVERSITIES or state Govt. in Maharashtra?

M.MAHENDRAN
28 Jan 2013

UGC announced to welcome in M.phil holder 2009 completer exempted NET exam ,qualified in lecturer post ,but after in M.phil and ph.d holder not exempted , how to possible ? NET exam june 2012 un expectation cutoff marks increased ugc very shock so NET exam cutoff marks consider to ugc ,currently researcher and m.hil holder mostly rural side and more difficult and workload in new announced to 15% increased cutoff against to whole india rural and village suffering student in future....

Sushil
27 Jan 2013

HI sir,
I am completed my M.sc. and M.phil also from NMU, jalgaon.
I have awarded M.Phil degree on dated 30 JUly 2009
Pl tell mi i'm applicable for Lecturer in Senior college
Pl send rules and regulations

manoj
20 Jan 2013

I am 100% agree with Dr SANJAY DHYANI...
It will produce good quality teachers comparatively .

manoj
20 Jan 2013

I am 100% agree with Dr SANJAY DHYANI...
It will produce good quality teachers comparatively .

Dr SANJAY DHYANI
07 Jan 2013

Dear sir,
Ph.D & M.Phill Programme should be essential qualification and NET should be mandatory.
Thanks

ashish
04 Jan 2013

Next hearing of m.phill case in supreme court is 07 jan 2013 case no is slp civil 36032 year 2010.BE POSITIVE

Dr.Manoj Kumar
30 Dec 2012

I want to know about NET relaxation. I Have admitted in Ph.D in May 2005 in Visva-Bharati University, thesis seminar in may 2009, thesis submitted in Nov.2009 and subsiquently degree in August in 2010.Therefore I request you to kindly give information regarding NET relaxation.

MONICA
17 Dec 2012

net should not be the criterion for lecturership as it is not based on research and hardly has any role in teaching.It can be cleared even by a matriculate.

Mahale Madhu Bavaju
13 Dec 2012

Rayat Shikshan Sanstha, Satara D.P.Bhosale College ,Koregaon
Maharashtra Government G.R.No.Misc 2003/143/V.S. – 4 Dates 23 January 2004
University Committee Silted ST Category History Subject Full Time post (as par Month 8000/- )
Appointment to the post of Full Time Lect. in History Subject
07/02/2005 to 07/02/2007 as par month Contractual basis Two Your as par Math 8000/-
University Teacher approvals
Maharashtra Government G.R.No.Sakirn 2004/97/04/V.S.-4 Date 31/05/2005
Maharashtra Government G.R.No.Sakirn 2004(97/04/)V.S. -4 Date 06/July 2007
University Committee Silted ST Category History Subject Full Time post (12/02/2007 to 11/02/2009 Two Your as par Month 8000/-)
I am working on a Contractual basis. I am M.Phil Degree award 04/02/2009
Institute Rayat Shikshan Sanstha, Satara
Ref.No./H.Edn./22883 dt.10.02.2010
Shri Mahale Madhu Bavaju ,M.A.,B.Ed.,M.Phil Lect.in History,
D.P.Bhosale College ,Koregaon.is hereby informed that the appointment order No.H.Edn.206 dated 10/02/2007 issued to him is continue in the same institute with same condition subject to conditions mentioned in the appointment order No. H.Edn. 206 dated 10/2/2007 along with following terms and conditions
1. Your appointment is on probation for a period of two Year from 4/2/2009
2. you should draw Rs. 8000/- + D.A. in the scale of
Rs. 8000 – 275 – 13500
Your appointment is made subject to approved of the University and Govt.
The candidates having M.Phil. Degree in the concerned subject are exempted from NET for UG level teaching only

kumar
14 Oct 2012

i completed mphil jan 2009 through distance education is valid....

kiran minase
09 Oct 2012

tell me about m.phil holders my m.phil done before 30 june 2009 what happend with mphil case in supreme court on 20july plse tel me

Dharani Dhar Deka
03 Oct 2012

I am serving as a lecturer since 31 Aug. 2001 and complited m.phil in 2011. As a existing teacher is there any examption from net/slet because I am at fixed pay scale Rs.8000 without any increments and revised scale? Please suggest me the solution...

V Prabhakar Rao
26 Sep 2012

I would like to have a copy of the UGC order exempting M Phil holders before 2008 from NET

rahnado jaar
03 Sep 2012

kya karen h.p. public service commision shimla ko kisi notification ka pata nahin hai.

Marigowda .K.T.
03 Aug 2012

M.phil degree is like Ph.d. But why ugc is change guideline and rules for again and again for M.phil degree. some university are awarding M.phil degree in regular course now days. In some state govts are also give the job. How ul tell NET/SET OR PH.D holdres qualifiy for lecturership. now days NET/SET OR PH.D qualit is very low. So plz give the exemption for regular M.phil candidates . hope for the positive replay.
regular candidates

Bhabesh Patgiri.
01 Aug 2012

It is shameful to have heard that the NET or SLET holders claim to be superior to the M.Phil and PhD. holders which prompts them to neglect other qualifications. Again, Most of the scholars who have been awarded PhD through regular course, incline to consider M.Phil. Or PhD Degree under Distance Education as fake and of lower quality. But the suspected grounds behind degradation of such Distance Education Systems and the Awards are present in the regular course-- PhD and M.Phil. If the awards of M.Phil. Or PhD Degree under Distance Education are to be disqualified, then why do the Govt. Or the UGC not close the Distance Education System ? It is clear that the amount of money earned by the govt (state/Central) from the Institutes and the courses under Distance Education System is Just, but the Degrees awarded by them are not just. What a bias and one sided decision it is! All are influenced by selfish interest to take the advantage of the position. This is going on in India.

Bhabesh Patgiri.
01 Aug 2012

It is shameful to have heard that the NET or SLET holders claim to be superior to the M.Phil and PhD. holders which prompts them to neglect other qualifications. Again, Most of the scholars who have been awarded PhD through regular course, incline to consider M.Phil. Or PhD Degree under Distance Education as fake and of lower quality. But the suspected grounds behind degradation of such Distance Education Systems and the Awards are present in the regular course-- PhD and M.Phil. If the awards of M.Phil. Or PhD Degree under Distance Education are to be disqualified, then why do the Govt. Or the UGC not close the Distance Education System ? It is clear that the amount of money earned by the govt (state/Central) from the Institutes and the courses under Distance Education System is Just, but the Degrees awarded by them are not just. What a bias and one sided decision it is! All are influenced by selfish interest to take the advantage of the position. This is going on in India.

Professor Venkata Raghotham
29 Jul 2012

The NET as the basic qualification for being appointed to a teaching position is a good policy and the UGC should not dilute it. With more and more Universities giving up the M Phil program, the NET must be made mandatory.

Professor Venkata Raghotham
29 Jul 2012

The NET as the basic qualification for being appointed to a teaching position is a good policy and the UGC should not dilute it. With more and more Universities giving up the M Phil program, the NET must be made mandatory.

king
25 Jul 2012

Mrs.Ananthalakshmi Mahadevan kindly refrain from speaking in general. Generalizing things may hurt people those who do their work sincerely .Hope u have cleared the Exam but how come grammar mistakes are evident in your comment?Cleared the exam like my friend who did by bribing 5 lakhs or cleared as a fluke like my another friend .....?

Pushpender dahiya
23 Jul 2012

Next Date of Listing 25/02/2013

Fatima
22 Jul 2012

Any news on 20/07/2012 hearing of phd /mphil exemption case
Special Leave Petition (Civil) 3 6 023-36032 / 2010

raghbir singh
20 Jul 2012

what happend with mphil case in supreme court on 20july plse tel me

Mrs.Ananthalakshmi Mahadevan
19 Jun 2012

This is regarding M.Phil holders exemption from UGC-NET. I was ex-faculty in colleges. The recent issues regarding higher education is clear that the standard in colleges is going down pathetically. As UGC-NET is only a qualifying exam why there are issues in qualifying it. As of other jobs are concerned ,may be in banking sector, public sector companies and for government services(where even for a clerical post )you need a qualifying exam. But institutions that has to build knowledge society refuse to test faculty and UGC also go by such decisions will put Indian higher education in trouble. I know my friends and ex-colleagues who worked for just 3 months to get a PhD degree itself. Then where is genuine M.Phil degrees. There are many who enrolled for PhD in urgency when UGC announced for a common exam or NET for registration fearing to attempt such tests. Consciously speaking there are many phD holders who cannot even draft a letter without grammatical mistake??? This is how the system of research in India work.Only way to save our educational system is to make NET compulsory for lecturer ship. I think there is no wrong in taking a qualifying test for such a responsible role in society.

C Gowda
19 Jun 2012

As per my knowledge, UGC as nor exempted PhD's without coursework, more over along with course work the present PhD's will complete only when you publish something about your PhD work in reputed journal, than only you are eligible to appear for Viva
More over each year twice UGC gives notification in Employment news regarding net. In that it is clearly mentioned Phd's according to UGC regulation 2009 only excepted from net. So simply making some fake news we should accept UGC regulation 2009 and for get MPhil and PhD's without course work

srinivas
02 Jun 2012

the exemption for net exam seems applicable to regular m.phils only. what about distance mode m.phils. it is very much disturbing as ugc -Distance education council approved all distance mode m.phils. since ugc has accepted the new norms as prospective, this should apply to all sorts of m.phils. let us hope in the future corts and Mhrd will make it.

harpal singh
04 May 2012

To
Respected sir
Good morning, i am ragistered on sept.2007 for Ph.D. scholar, department of Psychology. i face r.d.c. 21 dec.2009 after it i pass . i got foloship by icssr till 31 july. iam sure i submit our thesis on august 2012. plese inform sir i am valid or not valid for degree colleges job in govt. sector.

Rakesh Kumar Chadha
24 Apr 2012

phd /mphil exemption case detail
Special Leave Petition (Civil) 3 6 023-36032 / 2010
STATUS PENDING
Petitioner P.SUSEELA & ORS.ETC.ETC.
Vs.
Respondent UNIV.GRNATS COMMN.& ORS.ETC.ETC.
Advocate(Petitioner) MR. VIKAS MEHTA
Advocate(Respondent) MR. NAVIN PRAKASH
Appealed Against High Court Details - Not Available
Matter is Connected To Connected Details - Not Available
Subject Matter SERVICE MATTERS - RECRUITMENT/TRANSFER/COMPASSIONATE
APPOINTMENT
Listing Details Next Date of Listing - 20/07/2012
Tuesday,

Nomita
18 Apr 2012

Oh another three months, Indian Judicial system

RAVI
18 Apr 2012

SC case date after three month , see case no. and year 36032/2010

Nomita
18 Apr 2012

What is the news of the SC case? can anybody tell.

sureya
17 Apr 2012

supreme court case likely to be put up in the month of may as two weeks time has been given to advocate on record to submit certain documents

HENRY DAVID
14 Apr 2012

Can any one let me know what happened m.Phil exempted from net second hearing in da supreme court can some one please give me da case details

md khurshid hasan
13 Apr 2012

bhai koi mujhe batao k jo m phil mein allready 11 july 2009 se pahle enrolled hai uska kya hua kya woh lecturer k liye eligible hai. plz tell m and all indian. thanks...

md khurshid hasan
13 Apr 2012

dear,ranjan,
please tell me and all indian that what happened of mphil decisin which is enrolled before 11 july 2009 .

ARUP KUMAR MONDAL
12 Apr 2012

Any one told me about supreme courts decision regarding Mphil examption. As today(12/04/12) was its hearing date. This case was made for challenging Madras High courts decision regarding Net/set as the mandatory qualification for CSC(College service commission). I am very eager to know this.

Tilak Raj
12 Apr 2012

Dear Ashish,
Is there positive response to your court case 36032 in supreme court.

Mitesh
11 Apr 2012

what will those students do, who have completed or will complete their MPhil after July 11, 2009?
ot
Those who are completed their m.phil.( Enroll 1n 2007 and held viva in september 2010 and recevied degree in October 2010, is the exemption is applicable to all the m.phil candidates

Nomita
09 Apr 2012

Let us hope that 12 april 2012 will decide our faith. Let it be in our favour.

Ranjan
02 Apr 2012

Dear Ashish,
Please tell me "case type", and date of filing.

ashish
02 Apr 2012

m.phil exemption case in suprem court .The next hearing is on 12 april 2012.I hope we will get exemption. The case no.is 36032.

R. K. Chadha
28 Mar 2012

India is great and greatest are its way to access ones excellence in education. one of such innovation is UGC NET exam. In India ones eligibility for lectureship can be accessed in 5 hours through UGC NET exam. Totally rejecting the 3years to 5 years hard work put in by one in obtaining the Doctrate degree. Mera Bharat Mahaan?

pinal gohil
17 Mar 2012

sir my question is what is the current situation for getting jobs in academics in usa for a mphil holder?

S.D. Kahaley
07 Mar 2012

while completing MPhil students undergo rigorous training inthe area they opt for MPhil.and undertake hard and tuff field work for collection of primary and secondary data for dissertation.By-and-large the topics selected are related to grassroot level of the society,and a true picture of facts in towns and villages are brought out in dissertation. Thus the realistic view will be carried over to the next generation. Not honouring the degree at par with NET SLETwill mean distrust on our own academic institutions. Not only that the MPhil degree will loose its sanctity.Issue needs nation-wide serious thought.

md khurshid hasan
07 Mar 2012

this is not fair. p.hd wale disco mphil wale khisko sir ji p hd wale agar bade bhai hain to hum mphil wale chhote bhai hain aur ek ghar mein dono ka hissa baraber hota hai . isliye meharbani kerke jo bhi mphil student jisne amendment 10 july 2009 se pahle regestration 9mphil0 mein kerwachuke hain unhe lecturer banne ka mauka diya jaye. thanks.

Anjali Pradhan
04 Mar 2012

i have completed my Mphil on 2009 but instead of 10th july i have completed it on September. but in our result the session is mentioned as 2007-2009 so will this notification be applied to us or not please reply.

akanksha
03 Mar 2012

great relief to m.phil stdnts who passed out before 2009....dont confuse writing ur own something creative requires a good brain and hardwork.....and never mind i have seen myclose frnds cracking net in their very attempt,,,,,,,,those all belonging to creamy layers.....so....for general stdnts its all good.......

kaleem
02 Mar 2012

Dear Sir ,
am librarian in a school my qualification is M Phil in library science I have completed it in 2008.what is the current guideline of the UGC wheter am exempt from NET or not. Plz guide me in this regard .hope for the positive response.
Thanx and Regards
Kaleem

Ranjan Samanta
27 Feb 2012

Dear nnnn,
From where U get this news?Please, send the order if any.

nnnn
25 Feb 2012

@ Hemant: M.PHils asre not exempted from ugc-NET.Only p.hd registered before 2009 are exempted

HANUMAN SAHAI JAT
24 Feb 2012

What is the fate of the decision of UGC taken in their 472 meeting to exempt from net to Ph.D. holders who registered before 10th July,2009 for Ph.D degree. Whether they are exempted from net to be eligible for appointment as Asstt.Professor in Universities/Colleges. Please arrange to confirm about the same.

Hemant S Koli
23 Feb 2012

To,
Respected Sir
I was completed Mphil Social work in Feb 2009 ,but at that time i was not working in teaching sector .So my question is for this rule
( exempted)I am applicable or not.
please reply me........!
Thank You.

Satish
17 Feb 2012

Everyone is saying NET is an single day examination. If so why don't you clear it in a single day. Actually examination take a single day only but its preparation takes long time as well as deep knowledge of subject.

pushpender dahiya
15 Feb 2012

We have to learn to respect our own universities and their degrees. The basic question is why do we need to test someone who already possesses MPhil degree? We only do this because we still do not trust our universities. Instead of holding such tests, we should monitor our universities through peer groups and accreditation for their programmes and make them better in their education pursuit so that we believe in their quality of postgraduates, MPhil and PhDs. The MPhil candidates obtain their degree after a lot of hard work in universities, which requires submission of dissertation and collection of primary and secondary data. As per my opinion, NET or SLET cannot find a merit student only with a single-day long exam.

DATTA
14 Feb 2012

why not mhrd accept the ugc decision in 472 meeting any body ask to mhrd when chourt(hc ,sc) accept it.

alen
11 Feb 2012

Sir, I want to know the current situation of m.phil degree. What actually the difference between Net and m.phil. After completion of m.phil degree can a student be exempted in screening test of p.s.c exam.

Amalesh Kr. Dutta
08 Feb 2012

It is very nice to us and will be helpful.

ashish
08 Feb 2012

ugc net minimum required marks are not to CLAIM FOR QUALIFING NET EXAM.ie. the result is on merit basis.

p. dasharatham
06 Feb 2012

I enrolled my PhD with Kakatiya university warangal in 2007 June but not awarded, i sat for pre-phD exam and qualified it in 2009 before 10 the June. i have a doubt that pre-phD is whether equivalent to M Phil. l would like to know.

HANUMAN SAHAI JAT
04 Feb 2012

UGC decision made in 472 meeting to exempt from NET to Ph.D holders who registered before 10th July,2009 for eligibility to appoint Assistant Professor in Universities has been implemented or not.

sureya
03 Feb 2012

Dr abhay from where you came to know that ugc has decided to exempt m.phill candidates from net?is it the latest one or the old one.earlier also ugc agreed but mhrd rejected it

DR. ABHAY
30 Jan 2012

University Grants Commission (UGC) has decided to exempt all candidates who obtained an MPhil degree on or before July 10, 2009 from clearing the National Eligibility Test (NET) to qualify for a lecturer’s job.But when it will be implemented as no gazettee notification from UNIVERSITIES or state Govt. in maharashtra????????????????????????????????

veena
28 Jan 2012

it is so difficult to be a married indian woman and a student .It took me 12 long years to study for M.phil as my husband and in laws found my studies usuitable to their egos.BY te time I ACCOMPLISHED m.phil ,new rules for phd has been imposed .HOW DO YOU THINK THAT MAKES MY DREAMS COME TRUE . why SHOULD PEOPLE LIKE ME SUFFER DUE TO SOME PEOPLE WHO ARE WICKED DO WANT TO WORK HARD TO ACHEIVE THEIR ANDGOALS.

Dr.K.Premakumara
27 Jan 2012

It is unfortunate that those who are completed their Ph.D programme before 2009 are not eligible for recriutment as Asst.Professor.They must have NET.It say Ph.D degree awarded by any University on or before 2009 is not valid.They must pass NET or again they have to do Ph.D based on new UGC regulation.Realy it is unfortunate.Highest qualification of University is of no use before memory based test NET.

vinod warkad
27 Jan 2012

net and set relaxation will get after retirdment ugc giving pice of paper

Priya Gedam
25 Jan 2012

i had registered for M.phill in 2008 but degree awarded in 2010 in this case, im exempted for SET/NET or not.....................

ashish
22 Jan 2012

In ugc web site its commession decision 482 said that june 2012 net is fully objective in all subjects of social science and science also.ie.paper 1,2,3is objective.

tamilan
14 Jan 2012

dr.Sinha , are you pass net exam? if u cleared net exam u have right to say like this. if not.................?

datta
11 Jan 2012

what is the new notification in 2011 about mphil is exempted from net

Dr.B.K.Sinha
04 Jan 2012

It's not good to excempt the M.Phil degree holders from the NET.The NET filters the better faculty.Quality should not be compromised at any cost.Deserving M.Phil degree holders may qualify the NET.

ashish
01 Jan 2012

In ugc web site there is nothing information about net to be objective from june 2012

deva j r
01 Jan 2012

Respected sir plz send me a copy of Assam high court or case number & Assam higher Education decision about M.Phil exemption on my email id --prithvideva@yahoo.com
Thank you.

raghbir singh
01 Jan 2012

mr/mrs abc u r absolutlyright, nobody intrested in research.because no value of research and researcher in our country.why student spent our 3 or 4 years in research.after ma msc mostly clear net exam and take job and no contribute in research,mhrd understand research are the base of planing and planing are the base of devolpment.hrd need to motivate and help real,devoted and hardwroker research .and control on backdoor mphil and phd not on regular ,exempt regular mphil understand value of 2 or 3 years all mphil work are not equal

Ravi
31 Dec 2011

Wish u a Very Happy New Year!!!!!!!!!!!

pushker
30 Dec 2011

Cut-off-date must be defined for the regular candidates ....because those who registered in M.Phil./Ph.D. before 2009....and University follow the old rules for the registerd candidates....how is it possible to follow the new rules for the old ones when they are in final stage of completion......university can make new regulations for the next session when these rules come in existance.....

srinivas
30 Dec 2011

When will NET notification announce

Anand D Kharat
29 Dec 2011

I was register for M.phill in 2006 but degree awarded in 2010 can these are exempted for SET or net?

abc
28 Dec 2011

I know ur problem. It's very unfair on the part of HRD. He is mindless and keeps changing rule to confuse several budding scholars and teacher for higher education. ( See the link below: from June, 2012, all papers will be in objective types)

http://www.indiaeducationreview.com/news/ugc-net-candidates-can-now-eval...

raghbir singh
28 Dec 2011

i compleate mphil in 2008 from kuk as a regular and evaluated by panjab university chandigarh and i spent 2 years ,i work as a guest lecturer in a goverment collage and my result 100 percent and mostly my classmate take regular job on the besis of mphil and i take 2nd position in msc and mphil but mhrd says mphil not eligibility for lecturer job why many mphil work helpful for govt planing, all mphil holders are not equal,mhrd understand this thing. I give ugc exam in july 2011 and i qualify 1st and 2nd paper and 89 marks in 3rd paper disqualify due to only one marks in subjective paper and i am not reaveluate in 3rd paper beacuse no option in ugc i things that mhrd exempet regular mphil and change satructure of ugc exam only objective type question like csir beacuse its good method of evaluation

pawar archana devidas
25 Dec 2011

the candidates having register for M.phill in 2008 but degree awarded in 2010 can these are exempted for SET or net?

bidhan chandra patra
19 Dec 2011

MHRD told that Assistant Professor of Colleges and Universities will be recruited as per the Regulation July 2009, then how the question arises for cut off date for either M. Phil or Ph. D.
Although, Assam University and some 2-3 others advertisement published But there is no exemption to m.phil. Exemption to Ph.D. ONLY.
Who are right----------- MHRD or UGC or Assam University and others.

ashish
18 Dec 2011

UGC commission decision 480 & 481 publish on www.ugc.ac.in In this there is no net exemption clause. This clears that net exemption to m.phil is impossible. libexpress@gmail.com

ashish
15 Dec 2011

Assam university adv.published But there is no exemption to m.phil.Exemption to Ph.D. ONLY. For details see university web site.

prasad
13 Dec 2011

sir pls inform about mphil eligibility for lecturership and give me detail information about this case in supreme court.

suresh Tadibidi
13 Dec 2011

this is good news for who have got mphil degree and who registered PhD. we are thanking to UGC committee

Nomita
13 Dec 2011

Please provide supreme court case No,and year of exemption for M.Phil students.Also send me a copy of MHRD-GO Stating that all M.Phil holders (Before 10,July 2009) are exempted from UGC-NET and eligible for Assistant Professor in the UG level colleges. Its very urgent

datta
13 Dec 2011

sir pls send me hrd go and ugc notification at which mphil before 10 july 2009 is exempted from net at my email dmsolanke@gamil.com

ashish
12 Dec 2011

Give case no.other than 36032 of supreme court related to net exemption for m.phil. holder

Rajeshwari Sangolli
12 Dec 2011

Dear Sir
Please provide supreme court case No,and year of exemption for M.Phil students.Also send me a copy of MHRD-GO Stating that all M.Phil holders (Before 10,July 2009) are exempted from UGC-NET and eligible for Assistant Professor in the UG level colleges. Its very urgent.
My email id: rsangolli@yahoo.com
Thanking You

ASHWANI SODHA
12 Dec 2011

All candidates who want to know about s. court (m .phil) case no is36032(2010) & next hearing date is 11/4/2012

amol ghanokar
12 Dec 2011

Dear Sir
Please provide supreme court case No,and year of exemption for M.Phil students.Also send me a copy of MHRD-GO Stating that all M.Phil holders (Before 10,July 2009) are exempted from UGC-NET and eligible for Assistant Professor in the UG level colleges.
My email id: amol_ghanokar@live.com
Thanking You

preety singh
11 Dec 2011

My daughter has passed M.phil through distance mode in the year 2008.Now I want to know whether she is qualified for Lecturership in any degree college or not.If yes kindly let me know the supreme court judgement in this regard as well as the approval of MHRD.Please mail us on my Email:yogi_rashtriya@yahoo.com

ashish
11 Dec 2011

For M.Phil. exemption UGC agree but MHRD does not agree and Kapil Sibbal ignore our request. In such situation onlyone way to move towards ANNA HAZARE.Discuss exemption issue to ANNA HAZARE.We hope ANNA give some solution.

s.seenivasan
08 Dec 2011

Dear Sir
Please provide supreme court case No,and year of exemption for M.Phil students.Also send me a copy of MHRD-GO Stating that all M.Phil holders (Before 10,July 2009) are exempted from UGC-NET and eligible for Assistant Professor in the UG level colleges.
My email id: drseenivasan@gmail.com
Thanking You

K R Sharma
07 Dec 2011

Sir,
I am going to complete my mphil program from vinayaka mission university under distance education. I am really frustrated whether my mphil degree from vmu will be helpfull for admission to phd program. In this regard, please clear my doubts whether I can get admission to phd program without interview etc.

Thanks and regards

KR Sharma

lalit
06 Dec 2011

pls send me year of examption for m,phil students

ashish
06 Dec 2011

Thanks for providing supreme court case no.and year for m.phil exemption. This is our aim.

vikram
06 Dec 2011

aswani sir please provide year of te case also

syed moinuddin
06 Dec 2011

sir I student of m-tech i'm very much intrested in religious education i want to phd on religious, is there any posibility plz mail me syedmoin71@gmail.com

k.m.mohan
05 Dec 2011

I have submitted my doctoral thesis on november 25th 2010 in the subject education, i wish to know whether i am eligible to be appointed as assistant professor

Ravi
03 Dec 2011

thanks for providing the case no. of m.phil suorime court case.

lalit
02 Dec 2011

dear sir
pls send me infomation for the m.phil examption for the assistant professer recuritment pls any G.R for the information for the send me my any ugc rules and hrd rules send me e-mail id chauhan.lr@gmail.com

ASHWANI SODHA
01 Dec 2011

36032 case no of mphil in superim court

Dr.S M Bais
01 Dec 2011

sir, my friends are submitted Ph.D in the dravidian university coppam A P infrome me those Ph.D s are elgible for associate professor in Unversity

santoshkumar
30 Nov 2011

Clease m phil exmption mhrd G.O.Copy send me

Ravi
28 Nov 2011

sir/ madam
pls, if there is a case number of m.phil case in suprime court send me,
id- ravichem9@rediffmail.com

SABYASACHI BHATTACHARYA
27 Nov 2011

Dear sir,
Please provide me MHRD -G.O Copy stating that all M.Phil holders(before 10 July 2009) are exempted from UGC-NET and eligible for Lecturer post. is it applicable for state label elegibility test also. please send me the G.O of MHRD.

ARCHNA JHA
26 Nov 2011

SIR,
MERA NAME ARCHNA JHA HAI.MAINE 53% SE MASTER OF ARTS(M.A.)KIYA HAI.AUR PH.D REGISTRATION 1/9/2006 KO KIYA HAI.AUR MAINE PH.D DEGREE BHI PRAPT KAR LI HAI.KYA MUJHE KISI COLLEGE ME AS A PROFESSOR OR LECTURER KA JOB MIL SAKTA HAI?PLEASE TURANT REPLY KAREN.

Chandan Kumar Goyal
25 Nov 2011

I have completed my M.Phil. exam from TGOU, Nagaland. I had taken admission in July 2008 and given final exam in Dec. 2010. The result came in May 2011. Am I exempted from NET exam as per UGC rule for lecturership?
Please reply me.

Chandan Kumar
25 Nov 2011

I was registered at TGOU, Nagaland for M.Phil course (Distance Education)in July 2008. My Roll no. was TGOU/M.Phil/6.../Zoo/J2008. I had given M.Phil exam in Dec. 2010. Result was declared in May2011.
Am i exempted from NET exam as per UGC rule ?

Anilkumar.B.Kote
24 Nov 2011

sir i have completed my M Phil according to UGC 2009 regulation in central university of Karnataka in 2010. here my doubt is i am eligible for degree collage lecturer or university assistant professor ? and my M.Phil degree was equivalent to NET or SLET? am to much confusion regarding this so please give me information regarding this matter am waiting for yours reply........

Banne Ashok Siddappa
22 Nov 2011

This is Banne Ashok, Please send me a copy HRD's approval to the ugc's 472 meeting exempting the candidates who have completed m.phil. before 11th July 2009. My ID:
sadhabanne@rediffmail.com

RAVI
22 Nov 2011

All net affected people have to meet our state minister and say about net exemption of Assam Govt., Manipur Govt.,Panjab Govt.,verious High court dicission etc take out the same letter as net exemption,this is the better way.
All best.

RAVI
22 Nov 2011

In maharashtra several number of people meet to politician on net exemption,However, the HRD ministry had cancelled the decision of the UGC in March this year. A delegation of college teachers led by BJP MLA Sudhir Mungantiwar including college teachers from Pune, Nagpur and Mumbai had then met shree Rajesh Tope Higher and Technical cabinet minister of maharashtra govt. in this regard.
ID-ravichem9@rediffmail.com

T.S.Pandian
20 Nov 2011

Sir, I have completed my PG in Education with first class and also LLB with second division. Now I am about to submit my Ph.D thesis on Human Rights. Am I eligible to appear the NET in Human Rights and Duties.Thank you

Amit
19 Nov 2011

Find Assam Govt Notification from following Link
http://www.lisformats.com/net-set-slet-relaxation

s.seenivasan
19 Nov 2011

Dear sir,
Please provide me MHRD -G.O Copy stating that all M.Phil holders(before 10 July 2009) are exempted from UGC-NET and eligible for Lecturer post.

Mohammed Mujahed Ali
17 Nov 2011

will any one provide me G.O. copy stating that all M.Phil holders are exempted from NET and are eligible for lecturer post.
it is very urgent
please mail me

Ravi
17 Nov 2011

if the letter is coming from MHRD/UGC pls attach to e mail
ID-ravichem9@rediffmail.com

vikram
17 Nov 2011

mhrd and UGC should clraify about M. phil before 10 jnuly 2009 exemption from NET immediately.

ASHWANI SODHA
14 Nov 2011

Iheard that mhrd& ugc exemped mphil cut offdate. is that true? plz tell me on my email id as safikaithal@gmail.com

Ravi
14 Nov 2011

Now I heard that MHRD Ministry have passed the UGC cut off date proposal (UGC 472 meeting) for the M.Phil and PhD Candidates.If it is true, please send me a copy of the same and also send me a copy of Assam high court
ID-ravichem9@rediffmail.com

Ravi
14 Nov 2011

Now I heard that MHRD Ministry have passed the UGC cut off date proposal (UGC 472 meeting) for the M.Phil and PhD Candidates.If it is true, please send me a copy of the same and also send me a copy of Assam high court

Mrs. N.Kalithasammal
10 Nov 2011

Respected Sir,
I am Mrs.N.Kalithasammal,I have passed M.A (1993) with 63% and awarded M.Phil(1994) with distinction (i.e.80%). I obtained my M.Phil degree after a lot of hard work in the esteemed University,which requires collection of primary,secondary data s , field work,analysis and submission of dissertation. I registered(old regulations) my PhD in Delhi University w.e.f.20.11.2006.
Presently Iam working as Assistant Professor (Dept. of Economics) on Temporary basis (against leave vacancy) appointed by a duly constituted selection committee through the guidelines of UGC-NET second amendment regulations June 2006 since 08.01.2007. M.Phil and PhDare the highest degrees in our academic system and the present UGC-NET requirement (3rd amendment regulations) undervalues these degrees and affects my career also.
Now I heard that MHRD Ministry have passed the UGC cut off date proposal (UGC 472 meeting) for the M.Phil and PhD Candidates.If it is true, please send me a copy of the same and also send me a copy of Assam high court and Assam higher education decision about M.Phil students.
Thank you.
My email ID: jayakalithas@gmail.com

Kuddus Ali Ahmed
10 Nov 2011

College teachers who got admitted in or passed Ph.D on or before 9th July 2009(see admission) is exempted from NET. But in case of M.Phil they must pass or qualify on that particular date.My request is that the teachers who got admitted in M.Phil on that day or before, should also be exempted from NET.

koli hemant subhash
10 Nov 2011

To,
Respected Sir
I was completed Mphil Social work in Feb 2009 ,but at that time i was not working in teaching sector .So my question is for this rule
( exempted)I am applicable or not.

please reply me........!
Thank You.

K. S. Betageri
09 Nov 2011

Dear sir,
I K S Betageri, working as assistant professor in Rani Chahannamma UNiverasity Belagavi, have heard that MHRD ministry have passed the UGC cut off date proposal (472 UGC meeting) for the M.Phil and Ph.D. candidates. is it true?

Dr.Hari Mohan Yadav
06 Nov 2011

Sir,
I want to apprise you that my viva-voce has been conducted on 17 nov.2009,but I've received prvision certificate on 08 Jan.2010.Please tell me which date is assumed date of Award Ph.D. Degree.at my email id send a copy of court about exemption to NET.
(harry@rediffmail.com)

aliakbar
04 Nov 2011

only romour nobody have ugc notification regarding mphil exempted from net

Dr. Malay Ray
04 Nov 2011

I malay ray,I have passed M.A(56%),M.Phil,P.hD in Philosophy and also passed B.Ed. I awarded M.Phil degree in 22.02.2002. My PhD(old resulation) registration date is 04.12.2002.I awarded PhD degree in 03.03.2011. Sir please tell me nextly what should I do for the eligibility of college /university teaching proffession.My date of birth is 02-01-1973. At present I am 38 years. I can get age relaxation (37+5yr) through my PhD(old resulation) degree. Please give me this information.thank you.
My E-mail ID : malayroybdn@yahoo.co.in

Tilak Raj
04 Nov 2011

Dear sir,
I Tilak Raj working as assistant professor in CT group jalandhar, have heard that MHRD ministry have passed the UGC cut off date proposal (472 UGC meeting) for the M.Phil and Ph.D. candidates. is it true?

Jogesh
03 Nov 2011

Kindly send me the copy of Assam high court decision at id jkwadhwa@brbnmpl.co.in

Ravi
03 Nov 2011

Respected sir plz send me a copay of Assam high court & Assam higher Education dicission about M.phil as my email id ravichem9@rediffmail.com

ASHWANI SODHA
02 Nov 2011

Respected sir ,i have recevied Assam high court & Assam higher education dicission with ur help. sir now i want to know that is ugc,hrd & Assam higher edu. department ready to implement this dicission ? is this dicission implement in ASSAM STATE now days? plz tell me.

Aliakbar M K
02 Nov 2011

i think mphil degree holders future in dark ugc not issuing notification

ASHWANI SODHA
01 Nov 2011

Respected sir plz send me a copay of Assam high court & Assam higher Education dicission about M.phil as my email id safikaithal@gmail.com

ravi
01 Nov 2011

Vikram sir, please give me the letter of Assam high court dicission (verdict) on also case no.
email.id as,
ID:ravichem9@rediffmail.com

S DEY
01 Nov 2011

Sir,
I want know the current status of EIILM UNIVERSITY, Jorethang, Sikkim regarding UGC aproval is valid or not. Sir plz tell me about the UGC Aproval is genune or not. Since my daughter want to study in this (EIILM) University. Plz mail me giving the details regarding UGC Aproval of EIILM UNIVERSITY, Jorethang, Sikkim.
Yours faithfully

Subimal Dey
Email id: subimalchandradey@yahoo.in
Mob-9434756141

ASHWANI SODHA
31 Oct 2011

plz sir send me copay of Assam high court & Assam higher education dicission on email as safikaithal@gmail

ASHWANI kumar
31 Oct 2011

dear sir plz help me & send me latter of Assam high court & state higher education department dicission(verdict) on email id as safikaithal@gmail.com

Samtosh Kumar
31 Oct 2011

hello friends please any one give me exemption related gazette notification for moving towards court.

Ravi
29 Oct 2011

Vikram sir, please give me the letter of Assam high court dicission (verdict) on email.id as,
ID:ravichem9@rediffmail.com

ravi
25 Oct 2011

HAPPY DIWALI TO ALL FRIENDS.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! FROM RAVI

ravi
25 Oct 2011

VIKRAM thanks, I get the letter of assam govt. NET Exemption. but friend please give me the letter of high court dicission (verdict) on email.id as,
ID:ravichem9@rediffmail.com

NARESH GOUD
25 Oct 2011

In ASP Oriental College, Koti, Hyderabad, one lady lecturer, Smt Birudha Raja Ratnam passed UGC-NET 2000 exam in telugu on fake SC certificate and got lecturer ship in that college. Why authorities are not able to take action against her despite tahsildar(Nallakunta), RDO(HYD), District Collector Hyderabad have declared her that she got fake SC certificate? She is taking shelter in courts and enjoying the salary for the past 8 years, and continuing to serve. Is the administration and judicial system is so weak that she is commanding upper hand over constitution and judiciary system? A women is very powerful if she sheds the basic morals, violates constitution.. the law enforcing agencies have become mute spectators to her gimmicks. When she will be dismissed? Just type her name on GOOGLE.COM, you will get her details... Plz expedite the case so as to provide genuine SC candidate and punish her credentials as pseudo SC.
Do not allow her to take shelter with her gimmicks & corrupt lawyers support.

bandanabaishya
22 Oct 2011

I am B.Baishya, i am confused about my promotion.my placement on selection scale grade was due on 11.1.2007, but i have completed my refresher course on Nov 2008 and on Dec 2010 and get my Ph.D degree on Apr 2010. besides, i am a SC candidate. i want to know if there is any relaxation in promotion for SC candidate. please reply

Paramjeet singh
22 Oct 2011

sir, as the assam high court disabled the link but the reff. no. of case filed will be avaible. so please give me the case no.

Paramjeet Singh
21 Oct 2011

please tell me another site for the same because the said page not open.

Paramjeet Singh
21 Oct 2011

dear vikram , this link also not open , is any other place on the site where i can dounload the same. thanks

vikram
21 Oct 2011

assam govt. had issued notification after the judgement of assam high court to exempt m. phil before 11 july 2009 from NET. The copy of the judgement is not availble because link has been disabled by high court for judgement in dec 2010 but assam govt order and notification copy is availble at http://acta.org.in/downloaddoc/exemption.pdf

Paramjeet singh
21 Oct 2011

dear sir, can u send me the order copy of 'aasam high court issued order to consider m .phil before 11 july 2009 from net exemption'. please provide me the path where i can found it. you r requested to send it as soon as possible.

vikram
20 Oct 2011

acta.org.in/downloaddoc/exemption.pdf

vikram
20 Oct 2011
Amit
20 Oct 2011

Vikram can you send copy of the order of the High court or any information so we can search on website.

chandrika rai
19 Oct 2011

I am totally confused and i need right direction please help me to get a correct answer i have done M.phil economics from TGOU nagaland with 72% though it was distant mode exam i must say the university was so strict regarding the examination and thesis submission but i just want to know can i apply for the post of lecturer(govt job) with this degree and my second doubt is if i opt for phd will i be exempted from entrance test in UGC recognised univ in india?

vikram
19 Oct 2011

aasam high court issued order to consider m .phil before 11 july 2009 from net exemption

Pushpender dahiya
05 Oct 2011

We have to learn to respect our own universities and their degrees. The basic question is why do we need to test someone who already possesses MPhil degree? We only do this because we still do not trust our universities. Instead of holding such tests, we should monitor our universities through peer groups and accreditation for their programmes and make them better in their education pursuit so that we believe in their quality of postgraduates, MPhil and PhDs. The MPhil candidates obtain their degree after a lot of hard work in universities, which requires submission of dissertation and collection of primary and secondary data. As per my opinion, NET or SLET cannot find a merit student only with a single-day long exam.

Pushpender dahiya
05 Oct 2011

Net should be exempted in selection of a college librarian because this is full time technical job.Instead of 'NET' there need a huge experience In this field .It should be filled up by the promotion at least at college level.

SONA MISHRA
04 Oct 2011

to,
ugc team
R/SIR,
I AM FROM MP STATE. THERE IS A COURSE OF MCA,M.TECT,B.E(CS/IT),M.SC(C/S),BCA,PGDCA,B.SC(IT/SC),B.COM(COMP.APP.) IN MP. RATHER THAN THESE ALL OTHER COURSES(MBBS,LAW,MBA ETC..) HAVE ONE COMPULSORY SUBJECT AS A COMPUTER AND IT VERY SHAMEFUL THAT THERE IS NO PERMANENT DEPARTMENT OF COMPUTER IN GOVT. COLLEGES.WE ALL ARE COMPUTER LITERATE(EITHER NET,PHD, M.PHIL OR PG ), HAVING ONLY ONE OPTION TO WORK AS A GUEST FACULTY MEMEBER IN GOVT. COLLEGES, WHICH GIVES A LIFE OF UNCERTAINITY.PLZ. HELP US.
PLZ. TRY TO TAKE ANY ACTION ABOUT THIS MATTER.

Rakesh
30 Sep 2011

Dear All,

I do accept the Govt or UGC 's decision of making NET exam again compulsory is very ridiculous, and it shows how our policy makers are very immature and they are the playing with the life of many students who would otherwise have cleared NET exam had it been a compulsory.

The sad part is that those students who have already done M.Phil are not raising any voice against the Govt, and they seem to be more happy being remain silent.
I know it will be wrong if all M.Phil holders are considered as homogeneous group. Besides, we all know that teaching is an art. No degree nor NET can make a good teacher.

I also condemn the policy makers for changing rules and regulations off and on. It's not the mistake of the students. But the irony is that no M.Phil holders come forward and ask for their rights though they are the privileged and educated class.

Let's hope something done for many students who are unnecessarily suffering.My supports are with you and all who are M.Phil.

isha dhar
30 Sep 2011

all ready got one child scholarship under ugc scheme. For further assistance or she got the admition inMphil dgree course on Revensaw college.Fund is require to continue study.

Sanjay singh
30 Sep 2011

Dear Rakesh, I have completed my M.phil in regular mode. I have spent 1.5 years. I am always in favour of m.phil candidate and will be very happy when decision will come in favour of m.phil holders. It may take long time so my pupose was only for not wasting time.

vikram
30 Sep 2011

Dear Rakesh i agree with u. Some people who favours M. Phil exemption from net are now against the same after clearing NET. Now, to provide the justice to M. Phil holders before july 2009, UGC have to find out some solutionas as adopted by AICTE. In Engg. college a candidate having B.Tech. degree apppointed with grade pay of 5400 and a candidate having M. Tech or higher degree appointed in 6000 grade pay. After completing M. Tech the grade pay revised for B. Tech holder. The same secaneio can be adopted by UGC. The candidate having NET, Ph.D. may be given priority to M. Phil holder in recruitment and M. Phil holders may appointed after that and in a lesser garde pay. In this circumstance, i feel no objection raised by any NET or PhD holder and some justice may be provided to the poor M. Phil holders. I have done my M. Phil in 2007 because at that time M. Phil was exempted from NET and many people have got their degree after lot of hard work and research. Hence it is not right that all m. phil degree was purchased. I thking that justice will be provided to M. Phil holder after some time, may be after some year but many people will cross the age limit in that case.

gh
29 Sep 2011

@ Rakesh
I think u hd qualified UGC NEt that's why giving these type of comments. U r talking abt Distance education course but what abt the persons who had done m.phil as a regular course they too r suffering but u people r enjoying and satisfying ur ego. Anyway congrats and enjoy bcoz time is with u and we r suffering that will makes u more happy.

Sanjay Singh
29 Sep 2011

I have complete my M.phil in july 2008 when M.Phil was qulification for lecturer. But in 2009 it was rejected. I was very sad and read every news about exemption of NET. In Sept 2010 I had decided to clear the Net. Now I have qualified the NET (JUNE 2011). I have cleared NET in two attempts. So friends, dont waste your precious time and try to clear NET.

Rakesh
27 Sep 2011

Hi All,

See the UGC NET EXAM Dec, 2011 notification:

Read the point 5. ( Exemption part)
http://www.ugcnetonline.in/notification.php

It's clear that no blanket exemption for M.Phil and even Ph.D candidates who have not been awarded under Regulation, 2009.

jisha
26 Sep 2011

UGC NET should be made a mandatory requirement for the teaching post to assure the quality and standards required for higher education and the reasons to give exemption is in no manner justificable. Its a denial of justice and an unwanted compermise on the quality of education.

Rakesh
22 Sep 2011

How can some M.Phil holders, who got their degrees through correspondence or back door class think of becoming a teacher or professor. In my opinion even Ph.D holders should not also be exempted from NET. Having said that I can't solely judge a teacher-ship through NET exam, but there is no other mean to filter various candidates. I know hundreds of students preparing civil service exam in sitting happily in delhi and still continuing Ph.D or M.Phil from remote or distant universities.

Whatever the case! The decision of making compulsory UGC NET is good and even Ph.D should not be bared

Rakesh
22 Sep 2011

Dear ALL,

No M.Phil has been exempted from UGC NET exam. Kabil Sibal had already rejected the minutes of UGC. So, instead of arguing and hoping against hope, please prepare for the exam or fight for your rights in the court.

No action will come by simply writing comments and comments here...

Best Wishes!

vikram
21 Sep 2011

m. phil holders have been rejected in the hpsc recruitment.

md khurshid hasan
18 Sep 2011

i am open mphil holder but this degree is provide by tgou,nagaland after july 2009. my enrolled was in december 2008. my open mphil degree issuing date is march 2010.Is valid or not for asst professor in govt college plz tell me.

md khurshid hasan
18 Sep 2011

ph d wala disco, mphil wala khisko ,yeh kaisa faisla yeh to ugc ka sautele vyavahar hai. jaise ph d wale ko 10 july 2009 se pahle enrolled karne wale ko chhoot hai waise hi mphil wale ko 10 july 2009 se pahle enrolled karwlene wale ko net se chhoot milna chahiye tabhi hazaron enrolled mphil student ko insaaf milega

vikram
15 Sep 2011

an average of 5 candidates per UGC NET exam (Computer science) had clear the exam far behind the requirement of lecturers in computer science. In view of the shoratge of Lecurer in computer science and ratio of NET cleared candidates, UGC rethink on minimum qulification for lecturer in such subjects and M. Phil before july 2009 should be exempted from NET.

ranjan
15 Sep 2011

I am persuing phd registered before 11th july, 2009. Am I exempted from NET after awarded?

vikram
13 Sep 2011

what is the last decision regrding M. phil before 10 july 2009 exemption from net? plz post if anyone know.

karthik
12 Sep 2011

Can i get the lecturer post in corespondence m.com

b.v. sesha giri
11 Sep 2011

may i qualify m.phil degree in april-2009 is eligible or not

b.v. sesha giri
11 Sep 2011

correct result of qualification of degree college librarians as promotion

Pushker
08 Sep 2011

I request you please clarify or give me some reference for the following question....
"If someone has M.Phil Degree. Is it right that he will be exempted from Course work. Because MPhil Duration is more than One year and Course work is of one semester."

jutika
03 Sep 2011

what new regulation on m phil..plz inform me

vmv
03 Sep 2011

what about net exemption to m.phil. ? and what about suprime court case ?

neerajshonik
27 Aug 2011

mr. vikram go to ugc site and read notes no. 53 than tell me

vikram
26 Aug 2011

ugc is neither saying that they has rejected the m. phil exemption from net approved in 472th meeting nor they implemented the exemption. what the hell this is?

neerajshonik
26 Aug 2011

my dear ram i know what means regulation 2009 but i know what is latest regulation becouse somebudy sayes rejact regulation 2009 plz read all post than tell me what is latest regulation i read ugc site notes and read minimum qulification for lectureship is net what u say

vikram
25 Aug 2011

whatever assignment had been given to kapil sibal. he fails. he destroyed education system, fails to handle ramdev issue, lokpal issue, 2G scam . he should be thrown out from the govt.

ram bhise
24 Aug 2011

means those who has done their M.PHIL BEFORE 10 JULE 2009(regular,distance) they are eligible for lectureship in arts ,commerce ,science colleges ,where is circular of it ,where i will get it for reading

neerajshonik
24 Aug 2011

my dear plz clear me what is latest regulation of m.phil holder exm. net or not for lecturer job

Dr. L.R.Govardanan
15 Aug 2011

The question who deserves a position in institutions of higher education -- those who get through NET or those who get M.Phil. degree -- will perhaps remain unanswered for some more time. But how many of these candidates realize that the quality of their teaching, once they have achieved their coveted posts, depends very much on the quality of their medium of instruction -- English? The majority of the candidates who aspire for the posts of Assistant/Associate Professors are writing only the English of the literate. When are they going to consciously employ in their writing the language of the truly educated? This needs emphasis because the language of the learners is profoundly influenced by the language of the teachers!

Datta
13 Aug 2011

Recent decision of Nagpur High Court is that the mphil before 10 july 2009 is exempted from net but maharashtra gove.circular is not give.

P. Sreekumar
11 Aug 2011

Pūṛva paksham (ARGUMENT)
“There is a serious scarcity in number of teachers to be recruited to colleges for teaching computer science”, “There are very few people UGCNET/CISR qualified in computer science”, “There exists a number of people who qualified MPhil without UGCNET/CISR” Therefore, MPhil should be exempted.
There is a demand for x
x is not available
y is available
therefore;
y can be utilized instead of x
Imagine X is apple and Y is mango

Parapaksham (COUNTER ARGUMENTS)
For the last 15 years the increasing demand of software engineers for ICT industry made computer science BSc and MSc are the most demanded subjects in our colleges. Students who have minimum stuff have been easily recruited by industries. Very few of them from this group are interested in teaching profession.
1. The amount of initial salary they are getting at the entry stage in the industry is equal to the maximum salary of a teacher who can have at his exit stage of service. Industries are capitalist induced; as a result the performance based intensive is attractive in industry than the teaching profession. Therefore, few post graduate of computer science prefer teaching as a profession at the younger age.
2. Few of them have genuine interest in teaching than the financial benefit from the industry. They prefers teaching and they used to qualify UGCNET/CISR as simple as like doing a small Java programme. They know the art of programming, and they know how to demonstrate it to the students, therefore, they pass UGCNET/CISR and none of them in this nation is jobless.
3. There is an another category of people they work in Industry at the first stage of their profession (up to the age of 30 to 35) and come back to colleges with working experience and for better and calm life .
4. There is a last set of people, to them getting an MPhil is so easy than to get a job in industry and pass UGCNET/CISR. Therefore, they prefer MPhil without passing UGCNET/CISR.
If the demand for exemption is for 4th set of people, be aware, they are the people who are neither fit for industry and nor for research and teaching.
MPhil is a post graduate course; it can be done only after passing PG in the concerned discipline, if so, why they are not attempting the UGCNET/CISR. If they are not passing UGCNET/CISR means, we should be suspicious even about their level of knowledge at the level of PG. There is nothing wrong in belong ignorant in a subject with a PG in it, but that does not mean you should be selected to teach.
If there is more demand exist for idly in the market, will you supply anything like idly to satisfy the demand. Produce more idly and supply it without compromising the quality of idly.
Supply of teachers with anything like UGCNET/CISR is not the way to solve the problem of faculty scarcity in computer science. Few ways to solve it are given below;
1. Giving special financial intensive to young qualified to be in teaching position by generating money by the self financing of 50 percent of the computer course expenditure is one of the ways we can attract bright youngsters into teaching profession.
2. Attract people from industry irrespective of their age if and only they pass UGCNET/CISR.
3. Now there exist a mismatch between the demand industry and the content of teaching of BSC and MSC Computer science in India. Therefore, I found many of the students in my University are going for crash training of new programme languages after their PG to fit themselves into industry. This can be solved by engaging industry in providing teachers to collages.
4. Teaching Process Outsourcing (TPO) can be done with industries according to their demand and collages inability to give teachers for such tanning. A particular industry can provide the teaching service for a particular genre of technology for a collage according to their demand of human resource requirements.
These are few way ways we can solve the problem of demand supply disequilibrium in computer science course in collages.
Instead of the above solution or further, don’t fill the teaching post with the people who are not skilled enough for industry and to pass UGCNET/CISR. Higher Education sector is not a waste basket or a recycle bin, it is nursery for future, there we need good seeds (don’t misunderstand this usage in terms of genetics), but not the seeds which are not sold in industry.
P. Sreekumar, Asst. Professor
Dravidian University linguafranka@yahoo.com

vikram
10 Aug 2011

There is s serious faculty crunch in colleges for compuer science. Compuer science subject has been made comulsary in all colleges without appounting lectures. There are very few people NET qualified in computer science. UGC should exempt M. Phil from net for these type of subjects so that faculty can be provided immedaitely.

P. Sreekumar
09 Aug 2011

UGCNET is not a degree. It is an eligibility criterion to a Post graduate to be selected to teach in Universities and Colleges in India. M.Phil is post graduate degree. There are people who are having Ph.D and M.Phil in Public Administration. Can you argue to exempt them to appearing from Indian Civil Service Examination conducted by UPSC? Can you consider Ph.D and M.Phil in Public Administration and International Relation is equal to IAS and IFS?
How much a student spends in terms of money is not a parameters to fix the value of your qualification above the general merit. UGC must to conduct a study about the number of M.Phil awarded after 2006 by all Universities in Indian to unearth fact of “thousand of money in getting m. phil degree”. A student can buy a degree, but an Assistant Professor Post cannot be sold to him since he he/she is having a degree which not as equal to UGCNET. This is a high time UGC have to be more consistent on the operational measures to strengthen the standard of teaching of higher education in Indian at least by UGCNET. Next step, we have to implement the same standard UGCNET as a minimum eligibility to get admission for M.Phil and Ph.D too.
There would be many of lamentations for the weak set of people, (who are not weak in terms of social or economic backwardness but weak in quality because they are not ready to do hard work), but who will speak for the strong, one who are strong in merit, one who are strong in will and above all one who are strong and consistent in there handwork. Everyone have the opportunity to appear for NET, (there is an equality of opportunity and even relaxation also there), there is no age limit to UGC NET, there is no much fee like the above motioned investment for M.Phil. The demand of exemption of MPhil PhD should not be accepted. If a candidate is not able, and not ready to qualify UGCNET, let him/her go to other sectors of service.
If anyone is thinking that, i am arguing for UGCNET since i have job in University. I am not elitist, not even elite, and i am not speaking for elite at all. But let me state you frankly i was working as a casual labor during my graduation days. I do not suggest you too have to go for casual work to qualify UGCNET. But there is hard work for this exam. To me hard work for UGCNET is no ways tough than the hard work which i have done for the one daily wages in a Kerala village.
Like me there are number of candidates who are qualified UGCNET by hard work. Thousand of parents who are sending their children for higher education by hard work at field and factories etc are believing that their children are getting good and standard education. Therefore, the nation and its rulers should stands with the people who are having merit and people who need the merit for their emancipation and the development of our nation. If you are forgetting both we should call them the enemies of our nation.

P. Sreekumar, Asst. Professor,
Dravidian University, linguafranka@yahoo.com

vikram
09 Aug 2011

UGC announce in 2006 that M PHIL is also exempted from net. hence thousand of students enrolled in M. Phil and consume their valuable years and thousand of money in getting m. phil degree. May be some students gets degrees without making efforts but it does not mean that all M. phil degree holder gets their degree without knowledge and efforts. UGC should considered these students in making any policy regarding minimum qualifications and M. Phil degree holders before july 2009 should be exempted from net.

ravi
09 Aug 2011

my oponion that net/set is equalto nobel prise its not corerect why creat question on exemption?

DR T N MURTY
09 Aug 2011

Relaxation/ Exemption of NET for M Phil Candidates may loose the Value of Quality of Education and No need of conducting NET by UGC or SLET by State Govt.

NITIN SINGH
08 Aug 2011

CRITERIA FOR LECTURER IS SO SIMPLE ANYONE CAN BE A LECTURER AND NOW DOING EQUIVALENT TO BOTH NET AND MPHIL..STANDARD OF EDUCATION WILL AUTOMATICALLY GO DOWN AND WE WILL SAY EDUCATION SYSTEM IS NOT IMPROVING

NITIN SINGH
08 Aug 2011

WHAT IS THIS.A PERSON BY HIS OR HER HARD LABOUR QUALIFY NET EXAM AND HE OR SHE IS TREATED LIKE PPHIL DEGREE HOLDERS.THIS IS REALLY RIDICULOUS.WHAT IS THE USE OF NET,WE WILL NOW DO MPHIL...ONLY THATS THE SIMPLE WAY.DONT YOU THINK IT IS UNJUSTICE FOR NET PEOPLES

P. Sreekumar
03 Aug 2011

Students who enrolled M.Phil before 2009 also can write UGC NET. There is no age restriction for UGC NET examination, restriction is there only for JRF. Therefore, there is no question of injustice. NET may be easier to one who completed M.Phil, because they studied the subject one more year than the just post graduates (!). UGC can conduct NET exam for any number of students. Then the issue of injustice: UGC can prefer two types of justice; (1) over justice to the not qualified candidate at the expense of the diminishing of quality of teachers in higher education, (2) Justice to the merit and the resulted improvement of higher education in our country. If UGC and MHRD prefer the first option, the higher education in our nation is going to be in a sorry state indefinitely. In this context, if anyone argues for JUSTICE in constitutional terms our constitution is guaranteeing equality only in opportunity for employment, but not any relaxation of qualification of the concerned job except the reservation for deprived class. If the candidate is not belonging any deprived groups (ST, SC and OBC) they should not get any special justice since they have M.Phil and Ph.D. If you have old ICS can you make it as equal to IAS? Here there is no question of justice, but wants to liberalize the merit. Liberalization of merit and quality will make our higher education sector to week to face the storm of liberalization in the coming days. Already the process of liberalizing higher education sector is going in an extensive scale. Commitment to quality deserves constancy, and the set of people who cannot come to the level of merit because of social backwardness deserve justice and special concern.
Sreekumar, Asst. Professor
Dravidian University, AP linguafranka@yahoo.com

VIRENDRAKUMAR BARDE
02 Aug 2011

I think m. phil before july 2009 should be exempted because student enrolled in M. phil as per the rule of UGC at that time. if exemption is not provide to them that is injustice with the candidates.
In 2008-09 on NET aplication form an exemption for m.phil degree holders was mentioned Specialy therefore, thousand of sutdents were not attend the NET examination who is responsible for this? --- Virendra Barde

KISHOR S SAWAIKAR
01 Aug 2011

Yes this type of decisionby UGC gives oxygen to M.Phil and Ph.D. holders!

ravi
01 Aug 2011

i am qualifying net exam but i am not against the m.phil/p.hd net exemption, Hower ugc fillled lect. post with m.phil /p.hd and they were taken parmanent job that why ugc enter the candidate in system and make drama presently net exemption i will think that get permanent cut off date for minimum qualification , solve problem and lock the exemption. thanks

P. Sreekumar
30 Jul 2011

Higher education sector is not the place where we have to have compromise. I suggest UGC NET should be the compulsory qualification to enter into the Assistant Professor Post. Ask our Doctored PhD and MPhil candidate to pass NET. Off course Ph.D is a great degree, if so why a candidate who is having such degree cannot pas NET? It is like knowing about mango without knowing about the mango tree.
Therefore, i suggest both PhD and MPhil should not be equated with NET. Even UGC NET should be made as a mandatory qualification to do MPhil and PhD also. If s/he cannot pas UGCNET, let the candidate go to other sectors. Can you do M.Tech without GATE? Then why not NET? It is a disappointing turn, how UGC can talk about the standard of Higher education without implementing a standard consistently?

P. Sreekumar
30 Jul 2011

This decision will again unload a number of people who are not up to the mark to qualify the NET into Indian Universities. There should be an end to this excuse to accommodate those who have M.Phil and Ph.D “but unable to pass NET”. If a candidate cannot pass NET how he can produce Ph.D level knowledge in the discipline?

vikram
27 Jul 2011

i thing m. phil before july 2009 should be exempted because student enrolled in M. phil as per the rule of UGC at that time. if exemption is not provide to them that is injustice with the candidates.

Niza U. Khan
27 Jul 2011

At its meeting, the UGC noted that the UGC Regulations of 2009/2010 "are prospective and not retrospective in nature," and therefore resolved that "all candidates having MPhil degree on or before July 10, 2009 shall remain exempted from the requirement of NET for the purpose of appointment as lecturer/assistant professor."

In my view, exemption should be applicable to all candidates who have obtained a PhD degree on or before December 31, 2009.

DR. VINOD KUMAR
26 Jul 2011

if M. Phil. holder is eligible for the post of Asst. professor, what about the candidates who have cleared the UGC's NET examination and are still without jos. Despite avialability of many of the NET qualified candidates, The M.Phil holders are being recruited deliberatly ignoring the NET qualified. This is sheer injustice with the NET qualified candidates. Selection of the M.Phil. holder will be justiciable if NET qualified candidate is not available. In one of the Colleges where i appeared for interview, a M.Phil. Holder was selected. He paid 13 lakhs rupees. despite having NET-JRF, Ph.D., 10 publications in referred journals and teaching experience, i was not selected. ok may be i was not suitable. but there were many NET qualified deserving candidates who appeared for interview. Caste, Money are playing major roles in the recruitments of Asst. Prof. There are so many Questions and things to talk about. lets have debate. HRD Ministry should take sincere cognisance of malpractices prevailing in Higher Education.

SK
24 Jul 2011

UGC announces NET exemption cut-off date for MPhil holders in 472nd meeting. But in 473rd meeting, it has been ruled out also. Pl guys make it confirm and do the needful so that we, M. Phil candidates, may get the our rights back. pl check it out.

ravi
20 Jul 2011

my opponion is that government give equal dicission whatever may be happened ,now a day good dicission must be taken by ugc and dicied permanent amenmed for minimum qualification lecturer in india that solve all problem .

satish pandey
19 Jul 2011

i am a JRF-NET qualified and Phd holder but i am unemployed. i have various such friend's who are NET qualified but un employed. god tell us-- who will undersyand the pain of NET qualified's?

solanke
15 Jul 2011

net is compulsory for lecturer,there is no exemption from net

sudhir tupe
13 Jul 2011

sudhir tupe 13 Jul 2011
I am seriousely suggest burn all the mphil degrees in front of Hon.kapil sibbal. beacuse , on the other hand UGC (472)announces exemption, & HRD not accepts it. before withdrawal of MPhil exemption , thousands of candidates are got jobs. All are perment, and some candidates who are passed before 11 july 2009 but not in service, they are wondering here & there ( BOMBALAT) for job. no one can give them above 5000/- if these peoples do labour work in the field they got more than 10000/- then why peoples spend maximum amount on education. This all the game played by our Hon. congress goverment. If govt. thought we need some votes then they think & give the exemption 2 month later again he will withdrawals exemption, then after 15 days they will give the exemption. after 2 months again withdrwals the exemption. So i think this will be the long time INVESTMENT in mutual fund & swiss bank. Beacuse on the day of election VOTER - RAJA will forget all the things, and again congress will give the justice to poor Indian peoples and educaters monkeys.

vikram
13 Jul 2011

what is case no. & year of case pending in supreme court

Amit
13 Jul 2011

dear sir,
Sir what is the lattest news of M.Phil. today. bcoz today is hearing in supreme court. plz tell me about all things relatted with M.Phil.

Can I get exemption from NET? I have completed M.Phil in September 2008.

RAVI
13 Jul 2011

sir/madam
what about
the suprime court dicission about net exemption to m.phil(30 june 2009).

Mrs. Manjula Chaudhary
13 Jul 2011

sir/madam,
I have completed my M.Phl(mathematics) on May 2007. can i get a UGC Approval without NET/SET exam.
regards
Mrs. Manjula chaudhary

ASHWANI kumar
12 Jul 2011

dear sir i want ur help. sir what is the lattest news of mphil today. bcoz today is hearing in s court. plz tell me about all things relatted with mphil. i m confused.plz help me .

UMMED SINGH BHATI
12 Jul 2011

I have passes M Phil in Economice (With 65 %) in specilization in Mathamatical Economics,& MSc in Environment Science(65 %) , I wants to that Now as per UGC annoucement Mphil Candidates are eligible for college lectuer ship if its true pls share detailed information with confirmation for boost my confidance

Saurav Das
11 Jul 2011

this was a very retrogrative step. many bad blood entered the education stream thru this scheme.many MPil degree providing institutions issued certificates on back dates- the amount of money taken was collosal.
these rascals who managed to get thru must be made to pass NET/SLET in some stipulated time, else education is doomed

md haidarul islam
11 Jul 2011

sir,i m a ph.d. holder.sir , js phd degree lattest ugc norm,at present time?

A.A Malik
10 Jul 2011

I have been passed Mphil( Human right) examination from Global open university Nagaland and obtained 70% marks in Mphil examination . I want job in Education dept.

Rahmi Kochey
08 Jul 2011

i joined on 1st july 1999 as a lecturer in Nagpur university now R.T.M.N university. At that time my appointment was NET/SET conditional. I cleared NET exam in 2007. i wanted to ask from what date my service will be counted and also when i applied for PF acccount , it ws rejected , why ?

grace joe
06 Jul 2011

i have regisrtered my M.Phil in 1997 and completed the exam in 2010, but i have the course completed certificate as 1999, will i be eligible for lecturership with M.Phil. please guide me and help me out

Dr.G.Mohan Narasimha Rao
01 Jul 2011

What is the significance of the M.Phil. degree, if M.Phil holders are not exempted from NET/other eligibility exams from different states.Why the UGC/ Universities start and run the courses with out any value for that. M.Phil is not equaling to Ph.D, only intermediate course between PG and Ph.D. So there should be specific importance and purpose for that course.

Sudhir Verma
27 Jun 2011

we are m.phil student during the session 2008 -09 of Rajasthan. we hv obtained our degree in 13 december 2009. what is going on our m.phil case in suprem court... and Everyone know that M.phil degre is not completed less than 1.5 years, one year for course work and after six month is held for desseration and theory result. please tell me that how can be possible it , It is not justify for those students who has completed their Mphil degree after 10 july 2009 to december 2009. This a university fault because various univerisity set their exam sheadule and result. why we can pay this ugc rule and another thing is that supream court has annoused that Environmental Science is Complesury at UG level in the reference of Rajasthan state but all the UG level Government College avoide this Suprem Court Notice. How can we take this benifit and recently Rajasthan Public service Commission held the College Lectureship Examination 2011 but thet can't consider this complsury(Environmental Science ) subject. please give me a satifisfactry answer.

r. murali
25 Jun 2011

sir,
few student completed net and slet, many student compledted mphil and ph d please help me, aim assistant professor

jutika patir
25 Jun 2011

is any association approaches the Supreme Court in mphil regards? plz give information my mail

jutika patir
25 Jun 2011

is any association approaches the Supreme Court in mphil regards? plz give information my mail

yashingpha gogoi
21 Jun 2011

we are m.phil student during the session 2009 -10 of assam. we hv obtained our degree in oct 2010. what is going on our m.phil case in suprem court...we will also join any m.phil assoition..any how we will help...contect us.....yashingphagogoi@yahoo.com/ zyoteeka9@gmail.com

RAVI
16 Jun 2011

Pls give me detail aout m.phil case in Supreme Court .

ASHWANI kumar
14 Jun 2011

what is ugc minimum standards & procedure Regulation 2009 & Regulation2010? what tell about mphil both rules? plz explaion me.

Vaibhav Kulkarni
13 Jun 2011

Ramdev Baba is great . Kapil sibbal is a cheater. so that mphil holders before 30 june till job less. also some mphil holders are inservice but not got University panel that time , so these candidates not get approval from university.
so deside which political party is great .

vikram
13 Jun 2011

Is any m. phil holder approaches the Supreme Court in this regard?

ASHWANI kumar
11 Jun 2011

what is the future of unemploied thousands mphil holders today? who is responcibal behind this problam? is our education system or our policy makers? have our higher education today becamed wrost that after getting they can not help to get jobs easily?

lalit
11 Jun 2011

dear sir ,

what is decision for m.phil student?? pls help me

vikram
10 Jun 2011

M. Phil holders can get their rights only if Kapil sibal leaves HRD.

piush
10 Jun 2011

MINISTRY OF HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT
(DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER EDUCATION)
New Delhi, the 16th March 2011
No. F-3-7/2010-U-II—Smt. Mahasweta Levi, an eminent social activist and writer, was appointed as a National Research
Professor with effect 01/02/2006 vide this Ministry's Notification No. 3-2/06-U-11 dated 10.042007.
After being so appointed. Smt. Mahasweta has continued her work as a social activist and writer and has contributed
ith her work related to study of the rural tribal communities of West Bengal, women and dalits.
Therefore, in consideration of the continual work done by Smt. Mahasweta Devi, the Competent Authority hereby
appoints her as National Research Professor for a second term of five years with effect from 01.02.2011.
4. Smt. Mahasweta Devi will be entitled to an honorarium of Rs. 75,000/- per month in accordance with the existing
terms and conditions under the Scheme of National Research Professorship.
RAJENDER ICALWANI
Under Secy.
UNIVERSITYGRANTS COMMISSION
Newbelhi-110002, the February 2011
UGC REGULATIONS ON MINIMUM QUALIFICATIONS FORAPPOINTMENT OF TEACHERS AND OTHER
ACADEMIC STAFF IN UNIVERSITIES AND COLLEGES AND MEASURES FOR THE MAINTENANCE OF
STANDARDS IN HIGHER EDUCATION, 2010, (1st Amendment) Regulations 2011
F-1-2/2009 (EC/PS) pt.It—In exercise of the powers conferred under clause (e) and (g) of sub-section (I) of Section 26
of University Grants Commission Act, 1956 (3 of 1956) the University Grants Commission hereby makes the following
Regulations to amend the UGC Regulations on minimum qualifications for appointment of teachers and other academic staff
in universities and colleges and measures for the maintenance of standards m higher education, 2010, namely :-
Short Title, Application and Commencement :—
(i) These Regulations may be called UGC Regulations on minimum qualifications for appointment of teachers and other
academic staff in universities and colleges and measures for the maintenance of standards in higher education,
(1st Amendment), Regulation, 2011.
They shall apply to every university established or incorporated by or under a Central Act, Provincial Act or a
State Act, every institution including a constituent or an affilfated college recognized by the Commission, in
consolation with the university concerned under Clause (f) of Section 2 of the University Grants Commission Act,
1956, and every institution deemed to be a university under Section 3 of the said Act.
(iifi They shall come into force with immediate effect.
"In the University Grants Commission minimum qualifications for appointment of teachers and other academic staff
in universities and colleges and measures for the maintenance of standards in higher education 2010, wherever the following
pare occurs :-
- "Pay Band-4 (Rs. 37,400-67,000/-) with Grade Pay of Rs. 12,000/- per month"
It should be substituted with the following :-
"Pay Band4 (Rs. 37,400-67,000/-) with Grade Pay of Rs. 12,000/- per month has been replaced by the new HAG
scale of Rs. 67,000 (Annual Increment @3%)-79,000 with no Grade Pay. The AGP of Its. I2,000/- per month does
not exist anymore, Other conditions of eligibility to move the above scale of pay will remain the same. However,
the ceiling of 10% of such posts in the Central Universities and the criteria for eligibility and for performance
evaluation for this will remain unchanged.
K. GUNASEKARAN
Secy.
24—T9 Of/2011

piush
10 Jun 2011

this is fare in LOKSHAHI my classmede has pass m.phil and elegible for lect. but same (classmeds) student not eligible in presend day. what is this?

piush
10 Jun 2011

NEW GAZETTE(GAZETTE 13 APRIL 2011) HAS COM ON WEDSITE NO DETAIL ABOUT M.PHIL.

piush
10 Jun 2011

what is the final conclusion about net exemption?

ASHWANI SODHA
09 Jun 2011

when Kapil Sibil leave the hrd ministry. is that clear this problam is solved soonly? is kapil sibil & his tuglaki policies responsible of this problam?

vikram
29 May 2011

hope kapil sibl leave the hrd ministry in next resuffle probably in first week of june

Ameen
27 May 2011

When this exemption notice about Net Exam will be added in Ugc website ?

vikram
26 May 2011

nobody knows about the latest status of M. Phil exemption.

ASHWANI SODHA
26 May 2011

plz tell me about the lattest news of m.phil. is mphil pass before 09 is eligible for post of lecturer

vikram
20 May 2011

Is the UGC and MHRD thinking to provide exemption to M. Phil holders or the case is closed with no exemption

Sudesh Kumar Sood
20 May 2011

To, Dt.28/4/2011 Principal Secretary (Hr. Education) to the Representation Government of Himachal Pradesh,
Shimla.171002

Subject: Placement/Promotion in the UGC Selection grade Rs.12000-18300(Pre- revised), payment of up to date arrears and emoluments to eligible librarians.

Esteemed Sir,
Kindly refer to my earlier representations dated 09/06/2009; 26/10/2009; 15/01/2010, Private Secretary to Hon’ble Health Minister, H.P. U.O,No. PS/HM/H.Edu./2009/3121,dated 5/8/09, Secretary to the Hon’ble Chief Minister,H.P, letter No. Secy/CM-E0315/2007-DEP-C-203293, dated 11/03/2010 and Chief Parliamentary Secretary (MPP & Power/YSS), H.P, UO No. SPS (CPS-MPP &Power/YSS)/2011-6000, dated 4/3/11 and dated 18/3/11on the above cited subject. The applicant along with other eligible librarians are aggrieved as they have not been Promoted/Placed in the UGC Selection Grade of Rs.12000-18300 (Pre-revised) and their pay has not been subsequently fixed in the revised UGC pay scale wef.01/01/2006 in the entitled UGC pay band 4 of Rs.37400-67000+AGP Rs.9000. in spite of their making repeated chain of innocuous prayers and representations.

That the Applicant and other eligible Librarians submits as under:-

1. That the Applicant and other eligible Librarians (college cadre) are citizen of India and holding at present civil post under the Department of Higher Education, Govt. of Himachal Pradesh and is entitled to all the legal and constitutional protection available to him. As will appear from the submissions made in the subsequent paragraphs of this application, an injustice has been done to the applicant; therefore, he is filing and maintaining the present representation before the Authority concerned to get redress of his long pending legitimate grievances.
2. That they are holding the post of Librarian (College Cadre) UGC Scale in accordance with the Rules known as the Himachal Pradesh Education Department Class III (Technical) Services (Recruitment, Promotion and certain conditions of services) Rules, 1971, to be referred herein as Rules. Govt. of Himachal Pradesh, Finance Department vide notification No.21/2/65.Fin.REG,dated 06/07/1971 and even No., dated 12/10/1976 revised pay scales of Librarians to UGC Rs.300-600 at par with college teachers wef 01/11/1966. Applicant and other entitled librarians at Sr. No.2&3 were appointed in accordance with Rule 7(ii) b 25% by Direct Recruitment through the HPPSC initially in the pay scale of Rs.700-1200 vide Director of Education, Himachal Pradesh Office Order No EDN-H(1)B(8)3/85-5 dated 07 ‘ May,1988. The applicant joined the H.P. Govt. Department of Education as Librarian on 24/05/1988. Applicant no. 3&4 were promoted as Librarian as per Rule 7(ii) b75% by promotion amongst the eligible Assistant librarians possessing the essential educational qualifications prescribed in the Rules.
3. That Govt. of Himachal Pradesh in pursuance of the recommendations of the UGC to the effect that the Librarians will be included in the Scheme for revision of pay scales of teachers had already adopted UGC pay scales for college Librarians. It revised the salary scale of Librarians of College cadre wef 01/04/1980 to Rs. 700-1600 UGC, vide notification No. EDN-1(B)-7-6/77-A Vol II dated 29/03/1985.It also laid the essential qualifications for existing and future recruitments to the various posts of Librarians as per annexure’ ‘A’ and ‘B’ of the said notification respectively .Existing 5 librarians fulfilling the requisite qualifications were placed in the revised UGC pay scale of Rs.700-1600.
4. That prior to his selection for the post of Librarian in the Department of Education, Govt. of H.P. He was fulfilling UGC prescribed qualifications ie. Msc, + MLib.Sc. above 55% marks with consistently good academic record and was working as College Librarian in UGC pay scale of Rs.700-1600 duly appointed by DAV Colleges Managing Committee, New Delhi at the DRV DAV College, Phillaur. He worked there from 05/08/1988 to 23/05/1988 and consequent upon his direct selection through the H.P.P.S.C joined as Librarian in the Department of Education H.P. Govt. w.e.f. 24/05/1988.
5. That subsequently Govt. of Himachal Pradesh, Finance Department (Pay Revision Section) vide notification No. Fin B(7)-6/88 dated 19/05/1990, in pursuance of the provisions contained under explanation No.3(h) of the Rule-3 of the H.P. Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules,1988,revised the pay scales in respect of the Library Staff categories of posts under ‘Chapter’ VI Education. All 36 existing posts of Librarians ( College Cadre) ie.16 Posts of Distt Public librarians + 20 posts of college librarians) were adopted and revised to UGC scale w.e.f 01/01/1986 as under Sr.3 of the above mentioned notification:-Rs. 2200-4000 UGC Entry Scale > Rs. 3000-5000 Senior Scale after 8 years > Rs. 3700-5700 Selection grade after 16 years. This was applicable to the existing librarian incumbents only who came under the ambit of notification dated 19/5/90.UGC scale was to be awarded only to the existing incumbents subject to the conditions of UGC fulfilling the requisite qualifications or was applicable to existing incumbents on acquiring the requisite Qualifications prospectively. (See Note: “The conditions as prescribed in Punjab Govt. Notification No.10/93/88.Ed.I/3977,dated,6-4-1989,revising pay scales of Librarians of University & College Cadre and as adopted in H.P. shall be applicable in the matter of Fixation of pay, placement in Sr. scale/Selection grade, or other purpose as specified therein”.) All conditions have been incorporated in the H.P. Govt. Deptt. of Education Notification.Kha(15)-15/79-Shiksha-ka-1, dated 23/5/90. It also advised to make necessary amendments in the Service Rules as per UGC guidelines. It is also worth to mention that subsequently 45 posts of College Librarians were sanctioned in UGC pay scale of Rs. 8000-13500 in the new colleges opened time to time by the government. Prospective to 19/5/90 all posts of college librarians were supposed to be filled through H.P.P.S.C as specified in the said notification through 100% direct recruitment following UGC adopted guidelines.
6. That the Himachal Pradesh Government also notified the detailed Recruitment & Career Advancement Scheme of College cadre librarians on the Punjab pattern and recommendation of the UGC as specified above vide their notification No.Kha(15)-15/79-Shiksha-ka-1,dated 23/05/90. It also defined the nomenclature of existing “College cadre Librarians” and adoption of UGC guidelines for making future recruitments to the post of College Librarians through “Direct Recruitment only” through All India selection strictly following UGC guidelines only as in case of college teachers.
7. That the entitled Librarians (college cadre) including the applicant fulfilling the UGC norms and conditions as prescribed were on the recommendations of the Departmental Promotion Committee, placed in the revised UGC grades from the dates of their entitlement. The applicant was placed in the UGC scale from the date of his appointment ie.24/05/1988 vide the Director of Education, Himachal Pradesh order No. EDN-H (1) B (7) 16/85-5, dated 31/10/90. It is also worth to mention that the senior entitled Librarians were also subsequently placed in selection grades of Rs.3700-5700 vide Directorate of Education, H.P, office orders No Even dated 26/7/91 and No. Even, dated 22/3/95 on completion of 16 years of service as per CAS scheme 1986.
8. That in pursuance to the award of UGC pay scale of Rs.2200-4000 fixation at Rs.2200/- from the date of appointment i.e. 24/05/1988 was approved vide Director of Education, Himachal Pradesh, memo No. EDN-H (1)B(7)2/85-5,dated 21/11/1990.
9. That on the recommendations of the Departmental Promotion Committee the applicant with other eligible librarians Sr. no 2&3 were awarded and placed in the revised UGC Senior Scale of Rs. 3000-5000 wef.24/5/1996 i.e. on completion of 8 years of service as Librarian (college cadre) in the light of the Finance department letter no. Fin B (7)6/88, dated 19/05/1990 and CAS notification dated 23/5/90. The pay fixation of the applicant was approved vide Director of Education, Himachal Pradesh, memo No. EDN-H(1)B(7)2/85-5 vol II, dated 17/06/1997. Applicant is since 24/5/1996 stagnated in Sr.Scale without any futher promotion/placement in higher scale in spite of fulfilling all essential requisites for promotion/ placement in selection grade since years together.
10. That the applicants case was forwarded by the Principal, Govt. PG College,Nalagarh several times vide his office letters Nos.EDN/PGC/NLG/Estt-36/2002-03/1103, dated 18/11/2002, EDN/PGC/NLG/Estt-36/2003-04/1029-30, dated 14/10/2003,GCN/(Estt-36)/2004-675-76, dated 05/11/2004, EDN/NLG(Estt-36)/2004-1324, dated 22/07/2005, EDN/PGC/NLG/Estt-36/2006-2103 dated21/11/2006 and EDN/GCN/NLG/(Estt-16)2008-957 dated 17/03/2008 to the Director of Higher Education, Himachal Pradesh, Shimla, along with all the requisite documents for promotion/placement in selection grade. But am sorry to say that he has not been awarded his rightful and legitimate Selection grade entitled to him under the unrevised/revised CAS since no DPC have been held for placement /promotion of Librarians under CAS since 1998.
11. Subsequently the Govt. of Himachal Pradesh revised the pay of teachers and other Academic staffs in Universities and Colleges including college cadre librarians on revised UGC pattern vide notification no. EDN-A-Chha (7)10/98-loose, dated 07/05/1999 w.e.f. 01/01/1996. Director of Education, H.P. endorsed the UGC letter no. F-2-22/96(PS), dated 16/02/99, wherein Deputy Secretary, UGC informed that NET/SET is mandatory for appointment to the post of college librarian/DPE. The Proposal for Revision of R& P Rules of Librarians (College Cadre) were forwarded by the Director of Education, H.P. to the Government vide no. EDN-H /10A (3)1/90-4, dated 12/7/1999, and further comments submitted vide No. even dated 15/9/99. Due to adoption of UGC pay scale to the Posts of Librarian (College Cadre) at par with equivalent cadres of college teachers the classification of posts are also proposed as class I Gazette to be filled 100% through Direct recruitment. According to the Govt. Classification of Posts notification the posts in the UGC scale of Rs.2200-4000 falls in Class I Gazette category. Further the case was put forth to the Government vide Director of Education letter no. EDN-H (1) A (3)-1/90-4, dated 17/8/2000;20/9/01and 12/6/2002 respectively. The Secretary Education assured the H.P Librarians Association to clear the same in the Ist cabinet meeting of sept’2002, agreed in the proceedings of the meeting with the H.P. Librarians Association held on 03/8/02. Approved by Secretary Education, and issued by Director of Education vide Ednst. No. EDN-H (1) A (3)-1/90-4, dated 12/11/02. But fate of these proposed revised R&P Rules are not known and remains buried in the files only.
12. That as per the revised CAS-Career Advancement Scheme of 1996 the unrevised CASof1986
ie.Entry Scale >8years >Sr. scale >8years >Sel. Grade was revised wef. 27/07/1998 as.under:-
Entry Scale>6years > Sr. scale >5years (total service 11 years >Sel. Grade .>5 years>Fixation at Min Rs.14940 vide UGC notification F.3-1/94(PS)-7,dated 19/10/2006.
13. That the H.P. University had adopted the revised CAS as per their notification No.9-1/90-HPU (Genl) Vol-IV, dated 02/03/2007. Punjab Govt. adopted revised CAS for Librarians vide notification No.10/39/01-SE-1/2460,dated 20/9/07.
14. That the Director of Higher Education ,Himachal Pradesh forwarded the cases of CAS-Career Advancement Scheme of Librarians to the Govt. vide his letters Nos. EDN-H(1)B(7)3/94-UGC(Library),dated,16/01/2007,06/10/2007& 26/04/2008 along with the estimated arrears of each beneficiary librarian and requested that notification of revised CAS for librarians on UGC/Punjab pattern be notified at the Govt. level .He also forwarded proposal for DPC for placement/promotion of entitled librarians in selection grade/senior scale and recommended that necessary orders for CAS as per list of Librarians attached may be issued at the Govt. level.
15. That the proposal of the Higher Education Department received concurrence from the Finance Department vide No. Fin(PR) B (7)46/98-II ,dairy 50884480,dated 29/09/2008 with the condition that the Revised CAS-Career Advancement Scheme in the State be adopted on the Punjab Pattern and recommendation of UGC. The Arrears of difference of pay upto 30/09/2008 were to be credited to the respective GPF Provident Fund Account of the beneficiary librarians. In spite of the concurrence of the Finance department no action was initiated by the Govt. to issue the required notification of revised CAS or to convene DPC for placement of the applicant and other entitled Librarians in the revised Senior Scale/Selection Grades. Thus victimizing and depriving the beneficiaries of their due financial benefits without any cogent reason.
16. That all the above mentioned pay revision notifications stands automatically incorporated in the H.P. Technical Services Recruitment and Promotion Rules, 1971 as per provision-11 of the said Rules which reads as follows:-

Pay Scales: “Members of the services will be entitled to the pay scale as given in Annexure to these Rules subject to their revision by the Government from time to time.”
17. That the Department deviated all above pay revision notifications and proposed R&P Rules as per UGC norms. No direct appointments were made to the posts of Librarians since 1988. It continued filling several vacant posts of college cadre librarians by promoting school Assistant Librarians in violation to adopted UGC norms and service conditions as per obsolete & defunct existing R&P Rules 1971, initially as class III in state scale and subsequently also awarded UGC scales to several such promoted Librarians on just acquiring minimum educational qualifications ie. MLISc.(Masters in Library & Information Science) 55% (50% for SC/ST) giving relaxation in NET/SET, and consistently good academic record of UGC norms adopted by the State Education Department, in gross violation of UGC prescribed conditions, vide orders No.EDN-A-Chha(7)-20/98-1,dated 4/8/2006, and No. Even, dated 20/4/2010.and even dt.2/4/11.in the light of the Finance department letter no. Fin B (7)6/88, dated 19/05/90 ignoring UGC conditions as prescribed in Punjab Govt. Notification No.10/93/88.Ed.I/3977,dated,6-4-1989, adopted by H.P. vide notification Kha(15)-15/79-Shiksha-ka-1, dated 23/5/90, thus putting unnecessary burden of lacs of Rupees on the State exchequer. Exemption of these candidates has sparked a huge debate on the impact of the decision on the academic community. Exempting these candidates have paved way for a back-door entry, thereby affecting the quality of higher education. All posts of college librarians prospective to 19/5/90 were to be filled 100% by direct recruitment, strictly following UGC guidelines Therefore many such ineligible beneficiaries were not left out librarians, since their appointments have been made illegally in arbitrary manner through promotions from the school assistant librarians prospective to 19/5/90 and subsequent pay scale revisions 1996 / 2006 and UGC Regulations 1998 / 2008 /2010 ignoring adopted UGC guidelines. Relaxations have been given without obtaining any approval from the UGC.Your kind attention is invited to H.P. Tribunal, judgment passed on 12/10/04 in MA-1034/04 in OA-1239/2001 titled Chander Lekha and others vrs State of H.P through Secretary Education. Subsequent circular issued by the Principal Secretary (Education) to Govt. of H.P, No. EDN-A-Chha (7)/20/98, dated 11/10/2004 on the subject “Regarding award of UGC scale to Librarians clarification thereof.’’, to Director of Education clearly say that approval granted to you for awarding left out Librarians with UGC scale ,wide this Department letter No. even dated 25/9/03 & dated 27/12/2003 is applicable only in r/o those librarians who come under the ambit of this Departments notification no. No.Kha (15)-15/79-Shiksha-ka-1, dated 23/05/90, ie. The UGC scale is applicable only to those librarians who have been promoted to the post prior to 23/5/90, w.e.f. date of acquiring the Minimum educational qualification prescribed by the UGC. It is worth to mention that UGC in their Regulations 2009 has “Provided further that exemption if granted in any cases by state, shall be subject to the condition that the candidates shall acquire their NET/SLET/SET qualification, preferably within a period of 2 years, failing which they shall not be eligible for any increments in their pay scales and for seniority for the years of service rendered by them without such qualifications. The eligibility for increments and service seniority shall become operational from the date of qualifying for NET/SLET/SET or acquiring Ph.D. Degree as per the UGC Regulations, 2009”.
In the above connection it is therefore requested that cases of such ineligible librarians be rescanned for award of UGC scale, further increments/placements in the senior scale/selection grade should not be considered till all such promoted librarians do not fulfill the requisite guidelines as prescribed by the UGC to avoid any future litigations.

(Note: Above paras have been replied in affirmative vide information provided by the Department/Government in reply to my application under RTI, Act 2005. vide no. EDN-H(21)B(15)RTI-11/2009-SLN,dated 19/8/2009 and EDN-a-Kha(2) 1/2006, dated 30/10/2009 by the PIO, Directorate of Higher Education, H.P. and PIO-cum Dy. Secy. (Hr. Education) to the Govt. of H.P. respectively.)
18. That in pursuance of the recommendations of the UGC and Punjab pattern the Govt. of Himachal Pradesh, Higher Education Department revised the scales of pay of teachers and equivalent cadres including library staff w.e.f. 01/01/2006 vide notification No. EDN-A-B (7)-2/2008, dated 15/10/2009. According to which the teachers and equivalent cadres in library in selection grade with 3 years’ service are to be placed in Pay band 4 of Rs.37000-67000 + AGP Rs.9000/-. But due to inordinate delay in award of selection grade, my fixation was made in senior scale of Rs.15600-39100(PB-2) + AGP Rs.7000; vide Directorate of Higher Education, H.P.,Shimla office order No. EDN-H (1) B (7)7/2009-Fixation (RPS),dated 29/01/2010.Thus depriving his entitled due pay fixation. As a result applicant and entitled librarians are incurring heavy financial loss on their monthly emoluments.
19. That the Govt. of Himachal Pradesh, Higher Education Department issued the much awaited notification in respect of revised CAS-Career Advancement scheme to the Librarians (Government college Cadre) w.e.f. 27/7/1998 vide notification No.EDN-A-Chha(7)10/98-L,dated 01/07/2010, implementing UGC notification F.3-1/94(PS)-7,dated 19/10/2006,recommending Entry Scale>6years > Sr. scale >5years ( total service 11 years )>Sel. Grade >5 years>Fixation at Min Rs.14940 . It was also advised in the notification that the arrears of difference of pay up to 30/06/2010 shall be credited to the General Provident Fund Accounts of the concerned employees and cash payment will be made w.e.f.01/07/2010. But due to inordinate delay in DPC entitled Librarians are incurring heavy financial loss and victimization for their no fault.
20. That the applicant have been making repeated chain of representations to the Department for justice requesting convening of the much awaited DPC of entitled Librarians for their overdue Placements in the Senior Scale/Selection grade and subsequently make the payment of due arrears and up to date emoluments. Chain of representations have also made through e-samadhan vide application Nos.; HEDU/2009108;HEDU2009114;HEDU/2009115;HEDU/201033;HEDU/201045;HEDU/HEDU/2009105;HEDU/2009106,HEDU/201046;HEDU/201050;HEDU/201123;HEDU/201128;HEDU/201143,HEDU/2011175 but am sorry to say that no satisfactory answer has been received from the concerned authorities. The Directorate of Higher Education disposed off my grievances by remarks that the matter is under consideration of the Govt. It has also been informed that, the Directorate of Higher Education has resubmitted the cases of entitled Librarians for promotion/placement in the Sr. Scale/Selection grades to the Government several times, lastly sent on 31/12/2010. But no DPC convened till date. Time and again it is said that DPC will be done after finalization of Revised R&P Rules of Librarians. It is submitted that financial benefits are to be awarded retrospectively to existing incumbents and has no linking with the revision of R&P Rules since UGC scheme as a composite scheme already stands adopted in pay revision notifications as stated above. When all benefits have been awarded to the promoted librarians in arbitrary manner giving relaxations up to date, then it’s beyond understanding that, why the award of selection grade which is due in our favour retrospectively is being inordinately delayed causing us heavy financial losses in interest to be accrued on arrears to be deposited in GPF tuned to lakhs of rupees and up to date emoluments.
21. It is also worth to mention that the Proposal of revised R&P Rules of Librarians as per recommendations of the UGC submitted by Director of Higher Education, H.P. vide No.EDN-H(1)A93)1/90-4(R&P Rules)Lib., dated 12/2 2009 have already been approved by all competent authorities viz. Administrative, Personnel, Finance, Law and finally H.P.P.S.C has conveyed its approval to the Govt. vide letter No.1-10/71-PSC-part,dated20/01/2010 (College cadre Librarians) class I Gazetted and even dated 15/9/2010.(Public Librarians) State scale. But the Rules have not been submitted before the cabinet for Legislation for any cogent reasons.
22. It is worth to mention that the applicant had approached the Administrative Tribunal vide OA No.517 of 1996 as petitioner in case entitled Sh. B.L.Bahl and others vrs State of H.P. through Secretary (Education) to the Govt. of H.P to accord Class I Gazette status at par with equivalent cadre college teachers to the college cadre librarians in same UGC pay scale. But the State Govt. decided to revise the R&P Rules but failed in their persuits for 14 years. The Hon’ble High Court. has passed the judgment on 13/7/2010 in the said case CWP(T) 3085/08 directing the Government to do the needful as undertaken in their Affidavit regarding bifurcation of cadre of librarians and finalization of R&P Rules and according Gazette class I status, within a period of ten weeks from date of judgment. The Government was also directed to file an Affidavit in compliance to court judgment. But no tangible action has been initiated at the Government level to legislate and notify the approved Rules even after approval from competent authority since 15/9/2010 thus not even giving compliance to the Hon’ble High Court judgment even after lapse of more than 9 months. This has already amounted to Contempt of Hon’ble High Court Judgment.
In the above connection it is therefore my humble request to your good self for your sympathetic personal intervention and immediate redress of our legitimate grievance by convening the DPC immediately, instead of dragging applicant and other entitled Librarians into unnecessary litigations in the court of law for readdress of their genuine grievances and making payment of due arrears and up to date emoluments with interest of 12% p.a. from the date of entitlement and also seek all relief and compensation for inordinate delay in award of financial benefits to entitled librarians.
With warm regards.
Yours truly,
Entitled Librarians College cadre for placement in the UGC selection grade of Rs.12000-18300 (Pre-revised) and their date of eligibility.

1. Sudesh Kumar Sood, Librarian, Govt. PG College,Una, wef 24/5/99

2. Dr Anupama Verma, Librarian,Govt.PG College, Sanjouli (Shimla) wef 23/2/99

3. Sh. Urgian Chhering, Librarian, Govt. Degree College, Haripur, Teh. Manali wef 08/9/99

4. Smt. Laxman Dhara Negi, Librarian, Govt. Degree College, Theog,Distt. Shimla wef 21/10/01

5. Sh. Sonam Tandup, Librarian, Govt. Degree College, Kukumseri (L&S) wef 19/10/2k

Harish
15 May 2011

Indeed! What is the use of M.Phil degree when it takes nowwhere after rigorous studies of two years. Instead of going M.Phil, go for NET exam or prepare for civil service exam. What about those who have studied M.Phil thinking that they won't be required to qualify for UGC NET. And one worst morning, the news of compulsory UGC NET is making many aspiring teacher and scholars' life hell. Please consider the matters seriously and do something for the welfare of the budding and already working M.Phil teachers.

GUNDAPPA
15 May 2011

what is the use of M.Phil and purpose of M.Phil if Net was given more importance than M.Phil. only when M.Phil holders are exempted from net with out any frequent changes it is good to encourage M.Phil Course otherwise such courses can be cancelled in all the Indian universities when it is considered as unworthy.Some

MSW also it is practical Oriented only Bangalore University Students done in M.Phil what thet Degree Moreover the job of a MSW is different , required a huge practical knowledge and experience of this field. Only Net/SLET holder are less practically known about the subject.so this is my humble rquest to think over the issue positively and i am agree with thet UGC cut off is welcome

vikram
12 May 2011

what is the latest status of M. phil exemption? I have cleared Haryan public Service Commission screening test of College lecture and waiting for the intreview call.

A Teacher
07 May 2011

Dear Prof. Saurabh Singh,

Yes, there is nothing wrong in making NET compulsory for Lecture's job. The real issue is why UGC and the policy makers keep changing exemption. Had NET been compulsory, many talented students, who were busy doing M.Phil research, would have easily cleared the exam!

I totally disagree with the new rule of cancelling M.Phil exemption.

Prof. Saurabh Singh
07 May 2011

I do not find any wrong in making NET necessary for Lecturer's job. This dicision of UGC seems a surrender in front of a mob of candidates with compromised qualifications. Its simple, if you are competent, you should be capable of clearing NET. Why are you trying to hide behind a degree. Like even after being graduate you need to clear exams like IAS, CDS, PO, Graduate Trainee and many more, you are not selected for just being graduates. it is the merit amongst applicants that is selected. By doing so UGC has done a great compromise and has infact dented the quality of education delivery for two decades. As if any compromised candidate makes in, will stay there till retirements. It seems that committee which made decision had many compromised candidates in their near or far relations and therefore it can be infered that they want to force an inferior lot on Indian academic system.
Infact I wanted to humbly suggest that incorporate written examinations for promotion or selection from lecturer to reader to professor. This will curb corruption and nepotism.

Niranjani. G
06 May 2011

what is the use of M.Phil and purpose of M.Phil if Net was given more importance than M.Phil. only when M.Phil holders are exempted from net with out any frequent changes it is good to encourage M.Phil Course otherwise such courses can be cancelled in all the indian universities when it is considered as unworth.

Pushpender dahiya
06 May 2011

We are working in Delhi university and its affiliated colleges. Requesting for getting Net /Set exemption to MPhil holders who completed MPhil successfully before 30 June 2009. UGC or Some universities appointed MPhil holders for the post of Lecturer’s / Librarians before 12 July 2009 on the basis of Mphil and get approval from the university.
Moreover the job of a librarian is differennt , required a huge practical knowledge and experience of this field. Only Net/SLET holder are less practically known about the subject.so this is my humble rquest to think over the issue positively.

Romesh
05 May 2011

Dear Vaibhav,

I know your problems. There are many like u. Even in Delhi, I have seen many lucky people WITHOUT NET/SLET who have been selected as permanent faculty in several colleges of DU. Now, those several less lucky deserving teachers who have been working for several years have no where to go. Indeed! UGC and Hrd's policy is making many people's life hell.

vaibhav Kulkarni
05 May 2011

Respected Sir,

We are (MLOSC) Maharashtra Librarians. Requesting for getting Net /Set exemption to MPhil holders who completed MPhil successfully before 30 June 2009. UGC or Some universities appointed MPhil holders for the post of Lecturer’s / Librarians before 12 July 2009 on the basis of Mphil and get approval from the university.
Some fellows got jobs on basis of MPhil qualification but at the same time some candidates are working in various private colleges and at that time these candidates are also qualified on the basis of MPhil. But some collages are not get selection panel from the university. So most of the candidates’ are facing the problem for there carrier existence.
Recently in Oct 2010 UGC has given exemption for these fellows, (UGC 472 Meeting) but now HRD India (Hon. Kapil Sibbal) has not accepted UGC s proposal regarding exemption , and again second time we are cheated. Now we are facing the problem for our self existence in private institutes
Please help us.

Note: 1. Some AICTE Approved colleges like Management & Engineering are not required NET/ SET
2. Mumbai University has also given the approvals on the basis of First class only.

Romesh
05 May 2011

I do agree with your views that M.Phil or Ph.D degrees can be purchased like any other common commodities. In fact! I have seen many students who sit in Delhi preparing for civil service exams, and still pursuing M.Phil or Ph.D from 'remote' universities of India. Having said that it will be very unfair to devalue all degrees of M.Phil or Ph.D. There are thousands who honestly works for the above mentioned degrees.
I think the expert panel in any interview might be knowing the standard of the students. So, instead of debating if NET/SET would be compulsory for lectureship, let every selection board promises not to indulge in favoritism and corruption which is a slow killers of India.
So, I would like to conclude with the opinion that the recent exemption should be accepted so that those who have already spent lots of time and energy for their M.Phil or Ph.D should be acknowledged. Otherwise, there would be frustration, and the noble profession teaching will loss charms.
From my experience, I have seen several best teacher who are not NET/SLET. No wonder! Teaching is an ar

Romesh
04 May 2011

Dear Rupali

Yes, Direct Ph.D in JNU and several univs need to pass UGC NET...Something must be done...

Rupali Bhardwaj
04 May 2011

but wht abt who did their phd directly? means now there r also hierarchy in phd also, if u did directly then ready for cleqar NET exam

Rupali Bhardwaj
04 May 2011

Net exemption frm UGC only r tht who have pursuing or completed their phd according to new norms set up by UGC in 2009 means getting admission in PhD by entrance followed by coursework.

Romesh
04 May 2011

Dear India Education Review,

Thanks a lot for providing the information. From the article you recommended, it seems to me there is lots of confusion regarding the exemption, also every power centric person is exercising his/her sweet will regardless of general public interests. It's very disheartening though.

Any idea? when will be the next hearing? Is the case totally closed? Still confusing. Hope, there could be a final verdict.

India Education Review
04 May 2011

Dear Sir,
We have been covering whatever story comes out on NET-SLET decisions. As for this particular story, keeping in mind the relevance of the topic, our correspondent has done a full-fledged feature on the issue titled "Impact of UGC Regulation exempting NET for MPhil. holders"...the link for the same is http://www.indiaeducationreview.com/features/impact-ugc-regulation-exemp.... The feature aims to clear all the doubts of the reader with perspectives from former UGC vice-chairman Prof. S.K. Khanna and citings of various legal cases and decisions.

Romesh
04 May 2011

Dear India Education Review,

I find your site is so misleading. Why don't u update information on UGC NET exemption?

Romesh
04 May 2011

http://www.lawyersclubindia.com/news/Qualifying-NET-is-must-to-become-le...
By : rahul on 08 December 2010

Qualifying NET is must to become lecturer: HC

Degree of M.Phil or PhD will no longer be sufficient to secure a job in academic field in colleges as the Delhi High Court has upheld the UGC policy of making it mandatory for an aspiring lecturer to qualify National Eligibility Test (NET).

A bench of Chief Justice Dipak Misra and Justice Manmohan said the test is essential to maintain uniformity and quality in higher education as different yardsticks are followed by Universities while granting degree of M.Phil or PhD.

"The results of exams conducted by various examination bodies vary from university to university and they are, therefore, neither reliable nor comparable. Consequently, to attain the objective of common national yardstick in terms of qualification for every candidate who aspires to be a lecturer and that the quality of education in higher education is maintained at the highest level, the impugned Regulations 2009 were issued by the UGC," the court said.

The court passed the order on a petition filed by All India Researchers Coordination Committee challenging the 2009 Regulation of changing the eligibility conditions for the post of lecturers. According to the new regulation, only those who pass NET would be eligible for the post of lecturer.

Challenging the new regulation, the Committee said this was contrary to the 2006 regulation which held any one who acquired an M.Phil or PhD degree was eligible for the post of lecturer.

The court dismissed the petition saying the UGC took the decision after various expert committees have concluded that there are irregularities and wide variations in the grant of Ph.D./M.Phil. degrees in various universities.

"We are of the considered opinion that it is not for the court to question the wisdom of the policy directive of the Ministry of Human Resource and Development when it is based on the recommendations of an expert committee (Mungekar Committee) and there has been no violation of the enabling Act or that of any provision of the Constitution," the court said.

Romesh
03 May 2011

The Chief Minister of Goa Digambar Kamat has decided to give pay hike to contract basis teachers with PhD qualifications. The pay of contractual teachers will increase from the present 21,600 to 27,000 per month.

In March 2010, the state cabinet had hiked the salaries of contract teachers who had cleared NET/SET from 15,000 to 27,000 per month. Whereas the salary of contract basis teachers holding PhD degrees was hiked from 8000 to 21,600 per month. The latest enhancement to contract teachers with PhD qualifications brings both categories of teachers on par.

The move comes at a time when the University Grants Commission (UGC) has allowed teachers with Ph.D qualifications to be employed as lecturers. In view of this, the state government has now decided to bring the salaries of teachers holding Ph.D on par with those who cleared the national eligibility test/ state eligibility test (NET/SET).

[Source: Times of India]

(No more exemption for M.Phil holders)

Romesh
03 May 2011

Dear Vikram,

Yes, all m.phil should come together and make a move, so that the authority should learn they can't play with the life of academics. To tell you exactly, no more exemption fro the m.phil. HRD minister Sibal has rejected. Now, don't build castle in the air...no lectureship job for M.Phil unless one has NET or Ph.D.

vikram
03 May 2011

all m. phil holder should make a union and move into the supreme court for justice.
vikram_142@rediff.com

Romesh
02 May 2011

Dear All,

I find it's utterly of no use simply giving comments here. The fact is that HRD Minister Sibal has rejected UGC's new amendment of NET exemption cut-off date for MPhil holders. It's very unfair on the part of UGC and HRD. They can't keep changing rules at their will. Something must be done to stop the power play of some mindless law and policy makers.

I find it's not the case of debating if NET or non-NET teachers are better or not. The case is why on earth some dedicated and honest M.Phil holders are the victims of mindless and power thirst law makers. Besides all the candidates need to face expert panel in the interview.

The HRD ministry should simply give a green signal to UGC's proposal. All the victims and the academics should join in the cause in order to teach a lesson to the law makers that they can't play with the life of the budding academics.

chauhan Lalit
02 May 2011

sir,, i request to you pls any information for the m.phil holder pls send it and given deatils for the accepted for m.phil is lecturer in college

vijendra Singh
01 May 2011

When will UGC officially declare it? Why UGC is playing with the careers of thousands of M. Phil degree holders? without their official order, no recruiting agencies of various state are implement it. My request to UGC to implement it without any further delay

Surendra Mondal
29 Apr 2011

UNIVERSITY GRANTS COMMISSION
BAHADURSHAH ZAFAR MARG
NEW DELHI-110 002
MINUTES OF THE 472ND MEETING OF THE UNIVERSITY GRANTS COMMISSION
HELD ON 27TH SEPTEMBER, 2010.
The 472nd Meeting of the Commission was held on 27th September, 2010 in which the following
were present:-
1. Prof. Sukhadeo Thorat Chairman
2. Prof. Shivajirao Shripatrao Kadam Member
3. Prof. K. Ramamurthy Naidu Member
4. Prof. Xavier Alphonse, S.J. Member
5. Dr. Vidya Yeravdekar * Member
6. Prof. Achyutananda Samanta Member
Prof. Ved Prakash, Vice-Chairman, UGC, Mrs. Vibha Puri Das, Secretary, M/HRD and Mrs.
Vilasini Ramachandran, Aditional Secretary (Expenditure), Ministry of Finance could not attend
the meeting and they were granted leave of absence.
Prof. S.S. Mantha, Acting Chairman, AICTE, who was invited to attend as a Special Invitee
could not attend.
The following officers of the UGC also attended the meeting.
Secretary
Dr. N.A. Kazmi
Additional Secretaries
Dr. K. Gunasekaran
Dr. P. Prakash
Financial Adviser
Shri A.K. Dogra
______________________________________________________________________________
(*) Dr. Vidya Yeravdekar, Commission Member was not present at the time of consideration of
Item No.5.07
2
SECTION-1
1.01 (a) To confirm the minutes of the 471st meeting of the University Grants Commission
held on 12th August, 2010.
The Commission considered the letter dated 23/09/2010 received from
Prof. K.Ramamurthy Naidu, Commission Member and agreed to the following
changes.
Item No.1.01(a)
Page No.2 It was decided to replace the sentence “While confirming Item No.1.02(iv) it
was decided that letters received from Dr. Shivajirao Kadam and
Prof. Ramamurthy Naidu be also sent to M/HRD” with “While confirming Item
No.1.02(iv) it was decided that letters received from Dr. Shivajirao Kadam and
Dr. Vidya Yervadekar and the note from Prof. Ramamurthy Naidu be sent to
M/HRD”.
The following modification was suggested in the first paragraph at Page 10
relating to Item No. 2.08.
“The Commission further resolved that since both the above mentioned
Regulations are prospective and not retrospective in nature, therefore, all
candidates having M.Phil degree on or before 10th July, 2009 shall remain
exempted from the requirement of NET for the purpose of appointment as
lecturer/Assistant Professor. Further, all candidates who have either obtained
Ph.D degree on or before 31st December, 2009 and candidates who had
registered themselves for Ph.D degree on or before 10th July, 2009 and are
subsequently awarded Ph.D degree, shall remain exempted from the
requirement of NET for the purpose of appointment as Lecturer/Assistant
Professor”.
With the above modification the minutes were confirmed.
Action : Director(Admn.)

vikarm
29 Apr 2011

what is about implementation of decision? Now, recruiting agencies in various state are publishing advt. with NET is mandatory and only PhD based on 2009 regulation is exempted from net.
No one knows what is happening.

rohit
26 Apr 2011

Dear Seema,
The UGC site is working and you should fill the form immediately as today is the last date of online submission of the NET form.
India Education Review.

SEEMA
26 Apr 2011

Dear sir/madam
i m seema i m triying to fil the form since last 5 days but could not fill the same as UGC site is not working at all.i hv deposited the rs 450 through bank challan at SBI.plzzz help me.

Intekhab
26 Apr 2011

GR for NET/SET Exemption for M.Phil holders.
The GR is already there why u peoples are waiting for new GR.

dinesh kanchan
25 Apr 2011

The standard of all degress viz., undergraduate/post graduate/Ph.d. in India is decreasing exponentially due to government policy to encourage only Engg/doctor/management fields. Not only this, all corporate/industries prefer only B.Tech/MBA degrees whether they have requisite knowledge of the subject or not? Thousands of private colleges and govt run institutions are not producing engineers but distributiting certificate of getting jobs in different industries in India. It is clear from the fact that nota single technology Indian Engineers could innovate till now. We simply xerox the Japanies/German/US technology or buy it. Why their is a so much clamour for reducing the qualifiaction or quota for admission in education. What kind of study a 35% SC/ST/SEBC/ JAT/GURJAR student will be able to undertake in Engg./Doctor/Management? He will simply a burden on the exchequer and will be another RAJA or Mayavati or Mulayam or Laloo.
Kindly donot relax any qualification for appointment in education system and admission in any professional or basic courses. do away all quota system from education. Then only expect a strong and world power your country INDIA.

Dr. A.K. Sharma
24 Apr 2011

UGC must notify it immediately and it should be displayed on the UGC website.
The respective copy should send to the registrar of the educational institutions. As nothing is clear about the exemption. A candidate, who did the PhD from any university and which is not as per the UGC 2009 regulation. Who is responsible for it: candidate/university/UGC and.....
UGC must clear it.

ROY
21 Apr 2011

Comedy of UGC: UGC tells all the colleges and universities to reqruit NET candidates and silet about their salary. They never ever told and strict on the salary of qualified staff.

Dr. A.K. Sharma
19 Apr 2011

UGC must notify it immediately and should be displayed on the UGC wavesite.
The respective copy should send to the registrar of the educational institutions.

Dr. S.K Singh
19 Apr 2011

Don't make the rule after game has finished.
You can make new rules who want to register as PhD student not for those who are pursuing PhD or have Submitted their thesis according to UGC rules at the time of their registration. This is against the natural law.
Stop playing with career of the young brains of this country.

Ravi Saxena
19 Apr 2011

What to talk about the politics taking place for the selection of UGC Chairman. Even now-a-days the corruption in education field is so rampant that even the appointment of a peon is politically done.

It is marring the eficiency of our education system.

Lalit
17 Apr 2011

dear sir , i request to you please send me information for the m.phil is selected for the lecturer yes or no, if yes pls give me information for the latest news for m.phil for the lecturer

Pawar ravindra bapusa
16 Apr 2011

I have passed M.phil in 2008 Distance Education from Alagappa University.
Please Tell Me I am Qualify for lecture in Maharashtra Region.

Pawar ravindra bapusa
16 Apr 2011

I have passed M.phil in 2008 Distance Education from Alagappa University.
Please Tell Me I am Qualify for lecture in Maharashtra Region.

Prof. Karunakaran
12 Apr 2011

UGC has exempted M.Phil. Degree holders and it is a great relief for all of them, but what about the NET/SLET/SET qualified people all over the country. If Ph.D. Degree holders are also exempted what is the parameter and criteria on which the quality of research is examined by the universities?
Why is the UGC reverting its eligibility criteria for letruship over the years? Will it not lead to question the quality ad credibility of higher education in India? What is the MHRM is dong in India?
Are the NET/SLET/SET cleared candidates given priority for lectureship in higher education institutions, all over India? While there are thousands of NET/SLET/SET qualified people are jobless and underemployed and yet to be absorbed in colleges and universities, why give room for unethical practices by exempting M.Phil after a long pause?
It is high time that the UGC and MHRM have to evolve an appreciable standing eligibility criteria for college teachers.

If not, What is the need for conducting legibility test?

anil patil
11 Apr 2011

M. phil before July 2009 is exempted from net or not? the question stands since last 1 year. if anybody knows please publish.

Jayati
05 Apr 2011

Divisions are awarded by Central Universities prior to following grading pattern on the basis divisions (1st, 2nd, 3rd). UGC took a different stand by defining another division that is higher second division (55%) without any justification that candidate securing 54% from Central University can not appear for NET. I am a M.Phil./Ph.D. degree holder from JNU, but have secured 54% marks at Master degree level, passed master degree in 1993 from Central University Hyderabad. I am entitled to get relaxation for NET qualification, but 54% of marks at master degree is the hurdle for me to enter into lectureship.
Jayati

DR.T.E.PARTHASARATHY
02 Apr 2011

THERE IS ACUTE SCARCITY OF QUALIFIED PERSONS WITH APTITUDE TO HANDLE CLASSES AT COLLEGE LEVEL.ALL NET QUALIFIED PERSONS DONOT FIT IN TEACHERS PROFESSION.THE NET EXAM IS MORE SUITABLE FOR DOCT OTRATE ASPIRANTS.THE NET SYSTEM MUST BE DROPPED OR REPLACED BY ANOTHER PRAGMATIC SYSTEM WHERE PERCENTAGE OF PASS MUST BE REASONABLE ..NOT 3-5%

Mrs.SophiaJoseph
30 Mar 2011

what is the recent status of M.phil Lecturers under madras university.

surya
22 Mar 2011

there is no exemption for m.phill from net as we have confirmed from ugc. mhrd has rejected the proposal

vikram
18 Mar 2011

M. phil before july 2009 is exempted from net or not? the question stands since last 1 year. if anybody knows please publish.

harbir
17 Mar 2011

i did M.Phl in Jan-2009 from Vinayaka Mission University , will i'l be exeumpted from NET. Plz clarify...

Mithun Dutta
17 Mar 2011

Can UGC follow this site, if yes, then plz reply about M.Phil exemption from NET/SET or not.

chauhan lalit
16 Mar 2011

hi m.phil rejected or m.phil is accepted for the lecturere pls tell me i m confuse for the interview pls send me reply

Achla
11 Mar 2011

Thanx :):)

James
08 Mar 2011

It would be very nice if Indian Education Review can clarify the latest UGC position on the minimum qualifications for lectureship. There is a lot of confusion regarding the status of M.Phil degree holders--whether the candidates having their M.Phil degree before 2009 are given exemption. Another point that needs clarification is if the PhD candidates who had submitted their theses before 2009 are given exemption by the UGC. Uncertainty regarding this causes a lot of hardship to those who are always on the margins of the cut-off dates. Hope IER will notify the latest status.
James
Mahatma Gandhi University

surya
08 Mar 2011

tell me if exempting m.phill candidates from net is still under consideration or totallyrejected by MHRD

BIJU DHARMAPALAN
07 Mar 2011

Make M. Phil. Degree Mandatory for improving quality of Doctoral studies

There is a wide spread concern among the students regarding the value of M.Phil. degree. Many have serious apprehensions regarding the utility of this degree. They often feel that they don’t get any added advantage after taking the degree. Even though the number M.Phil seats is meager and getting admission is an arduous task due to tough entrance examinations, the M.Phil degree holders do not get the privilege they ought to get. In some universities like Jawaharlal University the M.Phil. programme is of two years and during these two years the students are made to undergo rigorous course work. It is said that getting a PhD from a state university is easier than getting an M.Phil from reputed universities like JNU. M.Phil as we know is a higher masters or a second master’s degree, of course lesser than a PhD.
The UGC has now made course work mandatory for all PhD programmes. Earlier course work was meant only for students of IITs ,IISc and some national institutions like TIFR, NCBS,JNCASR etc. Course work is one of the components to improve quality among PhD holders, especially in this era of multidisciplinary learning where people from different streams join for a PhD programme in a specific area. One of the problems facing the students of the national institutions is that even after one year of rigorous course work, if somehow they are discontinuing the course due to work pressure or some other reasons, students do not get any certificate. In effect their one-year is wasted. This drawback can be overcome by implementing M.Phil. programmes, instead of course work, before a PhD registration.
It takes a minimum of six months to one year for a student to get acclimatized with a new environment. In many of our research laboratories the PhD students has to face many problems related with unethical practices of supervisors and seniors. Initial days of a PhD student in a new lab are like an animal in a cage. He has to suppress his feelings and ideas and obey his master-both the supervisor and the senior student. Mostly the seniors, in the initial days will not accommodate a new student in their lab space. It’s a sort of ragging, even though it doesn’t come in the preview of ragging. The supervisor will give them guidance regarding to whom they should talk and whom they should avoid. It’s like slavery. For a sincere student who aspires to learn more in their subject area this kind of environment may a debilitating and they may be forced to discontinue the course.
Such situations are prevalent in most of our labs. One of the best ways to overcome this is do a course in the institution you prefers to do PhD. Either you can do your MSc there or join for a second master’s degree like M.Phil. that will provide an edge to acclimatize in the lab conditions. Most of our M.Phil programmes are designed in such a way there is an equal weightage for theory as well as research work. Its similar to or better than the course work of a PhD programme, so M.Phil degree holders should be exempted from course work and entrance examination. It would also be good to recognize the subject of MPhil on par with the subject of the basic degree, that is, if a student has his post graduation in chemistry and MPhil in Biotechnology he should be eligible for applying vacancies in both chemistry and biotechnology . A few years back UGC gave a notification stating that M.Phil degree holders can teach in undergraduate courses giving an edge to them, but now, again that rule has been reverted. Ofcourse M.Phil is not a substitute for PhD, but M.Phil degree holders should be given weightage for the valuable time they spend in research and learning process.

chauhan Lalit
07 Mar 2011

hi pls send me to the news for m.phil student for the lecturer in college

A Singh
07 Mar 2011

Till today no notification issued by UGC with regard to exemption of NET for M.Phil degree holder. when it will be issued. unless and untill it issued the status of NET compulsion is there.

Pushpender Dahiya
04 Mar 2011

This is a very good decission of ugc but can any body tell me where is the ugc circular about exemption..

ravi
03 Mar 2011

this is very good decission by ugc thanks to them it is life to mphil holders once again think you very much

Sujata Murlidhar Patil
03 Mar 2011

If the students compleated their M.Phil before 1993 are eligible for teaching? then why not I who have finished M.Phil in 1994?

kamlesh
01 Mar 2011

is there any hope regarding net exemption for mphil holders

kamlesh
01 Mar 2011

what is the latest status of m. phil exemption from net issue.

B.Sarkar
23 Feb 2011

NET exemption for M.Phil/ Ph.D holder before July 2009 is a good decision taken by UGC. However, I really respect TEST such as NET but simultenously I want to comment that the teachers who are on job around 10 years or more and have completed M.Phil degree through Regular or Distance mode from UGC recognized Universities, are surely eligible for exepmtion from NET.
Further, people normally neglect degrees obtained through distance mode.
If so, then why UGC recognizes such courses?
Again, I want to add here that we should not ensure that candidate obtaining any regular degree only will be fit for teaching. It is also true that many candidates with degrees obtained from distance mode are better than the regular candidates.
Finally, let me kindly remind that UGC has introduced the scope of higher education under DISTANCE mode for the employees who are unable to move from one place to another place, and the candidates who are lacking money.
So, as per my understanding, the decision of UGC regarding M.Phil is really appriciable. Although, I may suggest the standardization of the courses approved by UGC/AICTE to run in any institute / college/University not only under DISTANCE mode but also under REGULAR mode.

Muralidhara B L
21 Feb 2011

Is this not an easy way of entry for mediocre to University System? Will this rule uplift the standard of teaching in University System? Is the rule is made only to fill up vacant position or to uplift academic standards? Are we comparing M.Phil degree with NET examination? Don't we know how many a M.Phil and Ph.D holders have not cleared NET test in spite of their many attempts. Don't we know that many a M.Phil degrees have been obtained through correspondence mode. Don't we know how M.Phil degrees have been obtained by students. Are we not misleading the younger generation through this rule by giving them a message "there is always a short cut method for every thing" ?
I guess M.Phil degree is not a substitute for NET qualification. M.Phil degree is obtained by investigating on a particular topic. NET exam test the overall understanding of the subject of the candidate by looking at every single topic. The syllabus of NET is proof for this. When we look at number of people cleared NET we don't feel that there is problem of finding NET qualified. The basic problem of NET qualified not to enter into University system was pay scale and when UGC has revised the pay scale is there a need for such rule?
Rules can always be rolled back. I hope this rule will also be rolled back.

Vishal
18 Feb 2011

I have seen NET question papers. NET is great, a single point to test the capabilities of candidates. After all, there should be a single yard stick to guage candidates all over the country. States should not be allowed to conduct their own SET examinations. I strongly approve NET as qualification. Its only then we can give answer to the corruption which is there in education system of India. May be person is known to PM or CM or edu minister, if he/she is without NET sorry you are not academically capable to be a teacher.

Chandan Goswami
18 Feb 2011

I don't think UGC has taken a good decission. Because, all universities, which offers MPhil are not of same standard. Also that can be obtain ( I heard from various sources) in a sub standard way also. So a common test for all can be only solution for this. Please raise your voice to support NET-JRF as the only elligibility criteria for appointment in the university.

Misbah-ul Anzar
08 Feb 2011

1. NET exemption is not a good idea at all.
2. Eligibility for appearing at NET should be the point of concern. Thousands of students in the country cannot appear at NET because they could cot obtain 55% or were not awarded 55%at their Master's level.
3. If a relaxation of only 1%, 54% in stead of 55%, is given, thousands of students will be able to appear at NET and can get through it.
The concerned people should ponder over it without any prejudice.

vikram
04 Feb 2011

m. phil exemption from net gazatted notification will be published soon by the UGC

Santanu
03 Feb 2011

Hi Amitabha, I think your comment does not sound very great at all. Hope you will think some more time to write any comment or any conclusion.

vikram
03 Feb 2011

all m. phil holders should protest against kapil sibal, the blackman in indian education system

Dr.P.Panneerselvam
03 Feb 2011

It has already been rejected by MHRD ...

Chumki
03 Feb 2011

I request to UGC as early as possible your decision would be gazetted, because W.B. Govt. should be advertise on Asst. Prof. & Librarian post very soon.

Amitabha
03 Feb 2011

For College Librarian post it should be fixed that M.phil exempted from NET/SET, because they did not work as a lecturer and pay scale of College Librarian post should be reduced from Lecturer post, that is my opinion.

Rajesh
02 Feb 2011

First they allowed M.Phil. through correspondance and people did M.Phil. in science subjects through corespondance and now UGC is exempting these and equating this with NET. Let everybody be exempted from NET. Our leadership at the helm of these institutions is sterring us towards a disaster and day is not far when probably UGC would end up where AICTE is today.

vikram
31 Jan 2011

kurukshetra university and uttrakhand open university exempted m. phil from net in their emended recruitment notices

mujib md mustaffa
31 Jan 2011

what is the latest status of m.phil exemption from net exam for lecturer?. give the infromation in comments. put a fullstop for this everlasting crisis.

Dr Aniruddha Burmon
30 Jan 2011

Is the Inflibnet making a databse for PhD Theses? If so how do I register my thesis?

vikram
28 Jan 2011

what is the latest status of m. phil exemption from net issue.

Simon Jacob C
28 Jan 2011

I don't think M Phil or PhD is equivalent to NET. The decision made by UGC was perfect in keeping NET as the minimum qualification for the appointment of lectures in the colleges. Entire academic fraternity is well aware of the fact that certain universities confer PhD or M Phil without any academic rigor but merely by the so called "guide management" and even thesis are available on sale in the market. (so as case of projects for different courses)

Of course the one with M Phil/PhD in addition to NET can be given some additional increment or so but in any case no exemption from NET. The recent decision of UGC in extending the period of obtaining M Phil till Jul 2009 for NET exemption can be viewed with a doubt - to protect some one or satisfying vested interest of someone. This will again dilute the standard of higher education and more and more institutes come up employing unqualified teachers. To ensure quality education it is must that NET should be the minimum eligibility. In the case of school education TET should be made compulsory to ensure quality input for the higher education. We should not deny the fact that success is cumulative. It is not only the quality of higher education does matter but most importantly the school education.

sangeetha
24 Jan 2011

UGC announced that m.phil holders before 10th july are exempted from net. But in the recent notifications also it is not implemented. why ugc is creating this type of confusion among the applicants?

vikram
20 Jan 2011

what is the latest status for qulification of Lecturer in govt. colleges. Please post here if someone knows. there is lot of confusion since last 2 months regarding the M. Phil/Phd exemption from net.

vikram
20 Jan 2011

as per ugc latest amendment M. phil before 10 july 2009 exempted from net but recruitment notices shows the exemeption is only for PhD based on 2009 regulation.
the rule should be applied immediately.

Jitendra Kumar
19 Jan 2011

Its good that UGC has taken this kind of decision otherwise students will be going to court and after a long discussion huge money and time of Gov officer and Judicial system will waste. I thing government of India will take care this kind of action in time and before acting clear guidelines will be taken care theirin

vikram
19 Jan 2011

kapil sibble is not the right person for Minstry of HRD and Indian Education system. M. Phil should be exempted from net.

Boobathiraj.R
17 Jan 2011

Its good decision by UGC that MPhil is the minimum qualification for teaching because candidates who are interested in teaching alone are maximum doing thier research work. But many of them with their PG qualification goes to industrial field and if it gets down, they are diverting to teaching field without any interest in teaching but for a job. Then they are doing research activities for teaching job security. As the industries are mostly avoiding teachers to their environment, why can't educational institutions avoid industrialist employees to enter into teaching job without any interest. One solution for teaching eligibility in colleges hereafter is that, one / two year course like BEd/MEd for school eligiblity can be introduced (holding teaching methods, knowing students mental health awareness etc) and can be admitted with an enterance test by UGC after their PG qualification.

Vikas
14 Jan 2011

We are a student registered for Ph.D. in October 2009. UGC give exeption from NET/SLET, who are registered before July 10, 2009. I want to know that How can you say the students who are registered before July 10, 2009 are intelligent as same as the NET/SLET qualify students and those registered after July 10, 2009 are poor.

Nishad
12 Jan 2011

If a person passes MSc in second class and MPhil in third class before July 10,2009.Is he eligible to get exemption from NET?If a student passes MSc with more than 80% mark ,Can he be considered as NET qualified?In Tamilnadu MPhil is common and seat is more available comparing with Kerala.So MPhi qualification from Kerala l is few.So this exemntion will help those who qualify MPhil as part time /correspondance/distance/regular with just pass mark.Is it equivalent to NET?
MSc/MA first class with distinction Or MSc First class and MPhil first class should only be given equivalent to NET.Some students scored more than 90% in MSC level but because of unavailability of MPhil seat they also trying NET by working in different firms.What is your openion on this ?

V.Balasubramani
12 Jan 2011

What is the sin committed by those completed MPhil on or after July11, 2009?
The cut off date should be same as the date of announcement (ie. Nov 9, 2010). Who are they to fix some date and play with life of millions of youngsters?

Rajkumar V Kulkarni
12 Jan 2011

Consider M.Phil for UGC scale is not a good decision. Because getting M.Phil is not difficult in todays scenario. Our policy makers should rethink about the decision.

Yogesh
12 Jan 2011

Respected Kapil Sibbal Sir, I have done M.Phil only because M.Phil was considered as equivalent to NET/SET. If you do not want to consider this exemption, give me back my 2 years which I wasted to do M.Phil.

Can you do that for all?

vikram
07 Jan 2011

Somebody says that Kapil Sibaal has refused to sign the papers giving NET exemption to MPhil or Ph.D holders he has sent back the file twice to UGC. Sibaal is saying either do Ph.D again under new regulation or qualify NET.
What the hell this is? Kapil sibble should be replaced.

vikram
07 Jan 2011

as per ugc latest amendment"M. phil before 10 july 2009 exempted from net" but in new recruitment notices the exemeption is only for PhD based on 2009 regulation. Why?

Jayanta
07 Jan 2011

I have very much doubt about the M.Phil holder ( Correspondence), how they can teach ? It is not a good move.

Prof.Ashok R.Yedake
06 Jan 2011

i am very thankful to india education review because current and important news got from you, just one another important thing that please send information specially related to maharashtra education system and universities

Prabhat
06 Jan 2011

From July 10, 2009 onwards just getting M.Phil. is not enough. The candidate is required either to qualify NET or to do a Ph.D with certain "minimum standard".
Sub-standard - Ph.D's and M.Phil.'s are now filtered out. The exemption prior to this date is just a legal matter, since the "Standards" were set during 2009.

Ranjeev kumar chora
06 Jan 2011

Indeed a very good decision on the part of UGC.Mphil is also a global course which leads toward research.It is not always true that a Phd holder is always a better teacher than Mphil degree holder.Level of research In Indian universities are known to everybody.Therefore whatever the degree may be Mphil or Phd It does not matter but matter is your dedication towards profession and your students

Dr. C. R. Gautam
06 Jan 2011

NET exemption from M.Phil. Degree holder candidates really a very nice decision. It will provide the ample opporunity to yonngster fellow to prove yourself in teaching as well as research field. The major advantahe of this decision is that to remove the crisis of the teachers in the academic institution and Universities. Now my heart felt congratulation to all the students. I would like to give my sincere and gratitude thanks to the MHRD for the same.

vikram
05 Jan 2011

very good move by ugc, now quality teachers having m. phil/ph.d degree can teach the students and it will definately improve research and teaching standard in India

lovely
05 Jan 2011

A terrible move by UGC.
taking simple M. Phil mean diluting the quality of education bcoz this degree is easily earned just by throwing money. Those who really work hard and clear net/slet are being not treated properly in such scenario. the education seems to be only money based and every thing seems to be false. Whole system is fake when it cannot decide a proper justified decision and needs to change it every now and then.

Ramesh B
04 Jan 2011

1. Research and Teaching are two different things- a Ph.D holder may not necessarily be strong in fundamentals in all aspects of his field-he may have to teach areas which may be different from his research area-hence nothing wrong in giving weightage for such an exam
2.It may even be necessary to test the teaching ability apart from the test-again a candidate who cleared the test need not always possess teaching ability
3.If, for the sake of filling up posts, relaxation is done, it will lead to lowering standards - remember, a person selected remains in the Institution for the next 35 years(till now no mechanism exists to review such appointments-not only in India but also in Europe)
4.Future Managers,Engineers etc are moulded by teachers-hence teaching abilities and performance should not be neglected during evaluating a person during recruitment or promotion phases

Anu Right
03 Jan 2011

Anu Said:
most M.PHIL CANDIDATES ARE IGNORANT IN THEIR RESPECTIVE SUBJECTS,OTHERWISE WHY CAN’T THEY PASS NET EXAM?

Sanjay kumar Tanan
31 Dec 2010

Will revised the minimum eligibility conditions and recruitments….2010 after giving mphil exemption to NET if guzzete notification for this change notified or not.

Sanjay kumar
31 Dec 2010

Sir, i would like to know when the mphil exemption to net ugc’s 472’s latest decision comes into rule or notified or also tell hrd’s decision regarding this exemption,now no one is giving exemption in new recruitment. Reply soon

Aretha Lembke
31 Dec 2010

Sincerely, your piece goes to the greatest market of the matter. Your pellucidity leaves me desirous to understand significantly additional. I’m going to instantly grab your nourish to maintain up as a result far together along with your internet site. Alleging thank you is basically my little way of claiming excellent job for outstanding resource. Let In my nicest wishes for the inflowing publish

saji
31 Dec 2010

NET/SET really failed to test what it is designed to test. Community based variation in cut off mark has perfectly diluted NET. Questions are set according to
whims and fancies of the brilliant intelligentia who proclaim it to be of high standard. Sometimes no regard is paid to the syllubus that is published in the website. We need a test like IAS,IPS,CA,ICWA etc where caste ,religion etc does not form the basis of evaluation. Every where in the world quality matters but in India, “Community alone matters”.In kerala Brilliant brains are serving in the private sector for meagre emoluments while the less brilliant and efficient in govt /govt aided institutions. Let us all march to the dark ages. Throw the infamous NET and all other discriminatory things in to the Arabian sea.
Members of the Non reserved groups are not second to any one.we will prove if an impartial NET SET is conducted.

vikram
31 Dec 2010

is the MHRD give approval for m. phil before 10 july 2009 exemption to the ugc

Nandan
31 Dec 2010

this is good news for those completed the MPhil degree on cut off date where as bad for others .

T.Devidas
31 Dec 2010

If M.Phil Degree qualified for NET exemption, there is nothing in ‘10th July 2009′ to make it irrelevant. If it is considered that M.Phil is no longer relevant for appointment to teaching positions, the UGC is bound to give constitutionaslly valid reasons for its decision. Being “State” for Art.12, it has no power to make any arbitrary rule or take any arbitrary decision.Moreover, it has to be remembered that freedom once conferred cannot be revoked. Sec.166 IPC stands as enough advance admonition to prevent any arbitrary state action.
In many cases, candidates have qualified for the M Phil Degree in 2009 but Certificates were awarded on a later date depending on the date fixed for the Convocation.The rule prima-facie smacks of arbitrariness being without academic justification. If, arguendo, the 2009 decision is valid, the earlier exemptions were all arbitrary.
As it bears on equality of status and of opportunity for matters of appointment as teachers,it has to be challenged as void under Art.13(2) and Art.14 and those responsible for unconstitutional state action will have to be visited with appropriate sanctions.
Devidas

prakash
31 Dec 2010

The person who studied 10th class 10 years back and 10 years after 10 years will have the same qualification,(ie 10 th class). Then how can some be exempted for same qualification and others not exempted when the qualification is same. when a decision is taken on one day it should be in such a way that the decision will be effected from next comming batch or from the next comming year. But making it effected for the previous years is not a right or good thing as per me. for example they are giving chance for M.Sc students to do M.Tech but after doing M.Tech they are framing rules that basic qualification should be B.Tech with M.Tech. But how far this will be right for the students who did M.tech after M.Sc. Think in all aspects before decicing or giving decisions. M.Phil is the degree whether you do 10 years before or 10 years after. when NET is exempted for M.Phil students it should be exempted to all students who did M.Phil. giving exemption upto certain period for one degree and not giving exemption for the same degree for some other period is not correct as per me.

vikram
31 Dec 2010

there are various subjects like computer science where net qulifying sucess rate is very low i.e. .08%. so problems for govt. recruiting agencies to find out candidates against advtertized posts in computer science.
hence m. phil should be exempted in such subjects.

Muthu Kumar
31 Dec 2010

It is my opinion and finding if M.Phil degree is not taken account in the selection of Lecturer position it is going to extinct from the Educational Institute since there is no provsions of M.Phil degree for any post in India seeks M.Phil as a essential qualification other than for the post of Lecturer is’nt ? …….. Thus Ministry of HRD should equired to think wisely and act accordingly in this connection.

anu
31 Dec 2010

most M.PHIL CANDIDATES ARE IGNORANT IN THEIR RESPECTIVE SUBJECTS,OTHERWISE WHY CAN’T THEY PASS NET EXAM?

A.S.GANESAN
31 Dec 2010

what is present status for M.Phil exemption for Asst. Professor. Kindly tell me.

Tekbahadur Chhetri
31 Dec 2010

This is disgusting. UGC is playing with the future of India in respect of quality education in higher level. Some Universities are giving M.Phil degree through Distance mode, if anyone is qualified for the job of Lecturer they are who cracked the NET (as this is only the uniform system of qualifying for Lecturer jobs) Many universities and college service commission does not have clear direction about the value and necessity of NET.
So, UGC should make NET as a compulsory requirement for Lecturer/Assistant Professor.

vikram
31 Dec 2010

what is the latest status on m. phil exemption till date.
plz post it if anyone know

Smriti
31 Dec 2010

UGC should make basic sciences a separate paper for NET exam. Students who have done their Masters in either Zoology or Botany find it very difficult to clear because the questions are all from applied sciences… Most of the questions are from either Bio-Tech or from Bio-Chem… The basic Sciences are forgotten here…We request UGC to make Zoology and Botany a separate paper in clearing NET..Those who have done M.Sc in Zoology would not have studied more of Bio-Tech and Bio-Chem. Can anyone please take up this matter?

ritu
31 Dec 2010

I have strong reason to believe that UGC has something rotten at its core.Frequent change of norms mean that.I think deliberations at the core level with UGC are casual and not sincere.To me, these NET-SLETs are bogus at all.The indian education system will grow only if it follows a all india civil service like examination for education sector to accomodate qualified teachers. MPhIL and PhD are added hard owned qualifications.One should not deny/ deprive these candidates.Again, what are the similarities between NET and SLET, although both qualifies for lecturership. It’s ridiculous.

r.s.patil
31 Dec 2010

will somebody be kind enough to tell me what is the present policy of ugc vis-a-vis eligibility criteria fordegree college asst.proffessors post, has ugc exemted m.philholders or net is compulsory? plz reply

suresh s
31 Dec 2010

According to me,As for as UG courses are concerned there is no scope for research.Even in famous universities mojority of M.Pil and P.hd’s are awarded on the basis of caste,creed and religon.In karnataka it is difficult to get P.hd guides in science sujects for the students without background.Castisim played an important role in educational institutions.Hence it is better NET/SLET as mandatory qualification rather than M.Phil or P.hd.

Uma S
31 Dec 2010

16,000 students completed M.Phil in year 2008-2009 from Vinayak Mission University. Whether it is possible to University to provide guide and reserch support to 16,000 Mphil in one year. UGC and HRD both are aware about this fact and mentioned in one of thier report. From 1999 UGC on direction of MHRD stoped all Distance learning M.Phil.

If we are so claimed good future teacher why we are not able to complete NET? Court judgement is supreme and we also know funding body of UGC is MHRD. We have to respect Court verdict or MHRD, which will come very early. The Point that UGC earn 15 crore in year, but forgot expenditure to conduct exam.

If by the chance if you are not eligible by M.Phil, then it will be use full in later part of life.. but atleast come in NET pass candidate, NET is vey easy exam once you will appear with proper preparation.

Dr Uma S M.Com,Phil,UGC-NET,Ph.D(DSE)

sunil
31 Dec 2010

is 2009-10 M.phil batch eligible for assistant lecturership. if not then what is the use of that M.phil for the students.

admin
31 Dec 2010

is this only a discussion or any amendment pass in this concern if there is no amendments for this meeting then again opposition will take place to raise new issue over this matter.

Kanhaiya
31 Dec 2010

is this only a discussion or any amendment pass in this concern if there is no amendments for this meeting then again opposition will take place to raise new issue over this matter.

T.ramraj
14 Dec 2010

it is really a relief for those who have really worked for M.phil and more over it is a happy news for me. thanks to ugc and other various high court decisions.

Sasikala
14 Dec 2010

Whether it is possible for the MPhil holders obtained in august 2009 to get the excemption of NET.

ramesh
14 Dec 2010

can you say any body what is the status now whether its exemption or not

Manita
14 Dec 2010

Thanks UGC. This decsion has saved my 10 years of teaching and has give value to my qualification of M.Phil. in acadmics and motivated to work as university faculty… am very sure this is equally true for every person like me.

R Raman
14 Dec 2010

This is worst decision taken by UGC. The higher education in India is detoriated day by day and this decision has added more on this

Kewal raj
14 Dec 2010

U G C is requested to clarify the status and issue the necessary notification at the earliest so that the M. Phil.degree holders as well as the recruiting institutions may have clear directions . Enough loss has already been caused due to uncertainty and frequently issued inconsistent circulars.

ketan
14 Dec 2010

This is good decision i appreciate it .but i want to know is this for all those who completed mphil degree from Directorate of distance education or regular

once again thanks and congratulations

ketan

Padmakumar.N.
14 Dec 2010

I really am exhilarated about this move from UGC I would like to thank the Commission for the same. I have been waiting for the last five years to get a permanent placement in a local college where I am working as an honorary staff. I feel that this move from UGC will indeed help me fulfill my dreams.

SOHAN LAL KAUSHAL
14 Dec 2010

VERY GOOD DECISION. THIS IS TASTE OF REAL VICTORY OF STRUGGLE. I WANA SAY SPECIAL THANKS WHO STARTED THIS FIGHT AGAINST INJUSTICE. THANKS AGAIN.

jugnu
14 Dec 2010

The MOM of 472nd meeting are available on UGC website…….

Asir
14 Dec 2010

The decision is very good. But how to get the G.R and circular at an earliest so that before the norm is again change someone can get employed. Is there ink to get the circular over net. Kindly inform. HRD ministry opposed the decision of UGC in the court (on 10.Nov.2010). The court adjourned to Nov 22. Do anyone know the decision? plz inform me. the all india M.Phil. candidate plz made a unity.

A K
14 Dec 2010

UGC Net has never been a solution. Clearing NET/JRF and classroom teaching have no intrinsic logical relationship. On the one hand, Net is out-of-fashion, too rigid in structure; and on the tther, M.Phil and Ph.D. degrees are not classroom teaching. Hence, the UGC should be looking forward to a solution from the postgraduate level of teaching and research so as how to groom good teachers and and faithful researchers.

PR Krishnan Koushik
14 Dec 2010

The comments of the people will normally be biased. Again considering only NET/SLET will hamper the research activities in the education. There may be some people who might have purchased the M.Phil. degree.And it is not fare to punish the entire M.Phil. candidates. Fixing the last date for the M.Phil. degree will also block the research activities. It is better to consider the research degrees and NES/SLET as equivalents and at the same time make admissions and awarding the degrees to those who are worthy and fulfill all the requirements.

Dr. N.G.Raju
14 Dec 2010

I am very happy that the NET exemption has helped many post graduates who are looking for jobs. But May I get a copy of 472nd ugc meeting proceedings form some one who has it, or information from where i can get it?

Sanjay Sheoran
14 Dec 2010

The decision is fine. But how to get the circular at an earliest so that before the norm is again change someone can get employed. Is there ink to get the circular over net. Kindly inform. HRD ministry opposed the decision of UGC in the court (on 10.Nov.2010). The court adjourned to Nov 22. Do anyone know the decision? plz inform

manoj
14 Dec 2010

it is a very good decision because , it will be benificial for the teachers those who have completed more than 10years of teaching experiences having Mphil degree.

Sidhu singh
14 Dec 2010

What about the madras high court decision on 22nd November 2010? Please help.

anand
14 Dec 2010

In fact this decision is victory of struggle of thousands of
young teachers.thanks ugc.

chandra
14 Dec 2010

I have registered for Mphil in 2007, but due to my bad luck i only took my exams in 2008 and cleared subjects, and thesis submission in 2010 april, i have a waste Mphil certficate now, such things happen in India only. same qualification in two time duration has different validity this shows our educational advancement. those who are interested to go for court petition can move with a team, as UGC again has taken some stupid decision by extending upto June 2009, we need it to get it extended it as per admission date or for june 2010-2011.

HM
14 Dec 2010

I AGREE WITH GIRI THAT M.PHIL DEGREE CAN BE PURCHASED. BUT IT IS BENEFICIAL FOR THOSE WHO HAVE WORKED HARD TO GET THAT DEGREE ON TIME. SO I THINK UGC HAS TAKEN RIGHT DECISION. UGC SHOULD IMPOSE RESTRICTION THAT EXEMPTION IS ONLY FOR THOSE WHO OBTAIN REGULAR M.PHIL. DEGREE

BEERESH M. BEVINAMARADA K.E.S
14 Dec 2010

ITS VERY GOOD DECISION TO QUALITY STUDENTS.

BEERESH MANJAPPA BEVINAMARADA
B.Ed,M.A.In HISTORY,M.A.In KANNADA, NET,KES

Sony
14 Dec 2010

HRD ministry opposed the decision of UGC in the court (on 10.Nov.2010). The court adjourned to Nov 22. Do anyone know the decision? I have registered for PhD before July 2008. And I will submit my thesis on 2011 January 25. Shall I apply for a post now????????? Pls reply…. And I heard that the decision is to give exemption for those who have M Phil or registered for PhD before 2007 July.. Is it true.. Pls help us to find it……

R singh
14 Dec 2010

This is a foolish decision. This will damage the complete higher education system in India. Also this will create more injustices for NET qualified candidates.This is so sad, a candidate after clearing any other comptative exam gets job immediately whereas even after passing NET student gets only certificate. Why the Net is being conducted is a big question? Many students secured their M.Phil. from distance mode from some University without doing any kind of work. Such M.Phil students are from the family of Management of the private colleges and they appointed them. Also the lecturer post had been purchased by candidates paying upto 30L. This all are the work of education mafias and they have also purchased UGC.

Arvind Tayade
14 Dec 2010

This is a very GOOD Decision of UGC and also HRD Ministry is in favour of M.Phil/Ph.D.students.It is also applicable for those who are already in service. So please release the Notification/GR regarding this.

Malhari Ramchandra Wagh
14 Dec 2010

This decision is very helpful to M.phil holder persons…. do the same GR for All University’s and make happy to all Mphill. holder’s…. thanks

Devaleena
14 Dec 2010

PhD and Net are absolutely two divergent extremes and once a research scholar starts his/her research its difficult to crack NET at the same time. PhD involves a through hard work with complete devotion and absolute concentration. In such a scenario its difficult to prepare anything else at the same time. There are many students who are pursuing PhD just after their Masters. I registered for my PhD in 2008 just after my Masters. I think UGC should exempt also candidates who have started their Research works with the conditions that they also can apply for full time lecturer/ assistant Professor’s post when they will be awarded with their Doctoral Degree.

Aniket
14 Dec 2010

People who call themselves TEACHERS and are in service should be ashamed of demanding exemption from SET/NET. THERE IS NOTHING MORE THAN SOME BASIC THINGS WHICH ARE TESTED FOR IN THESE EXAMINATIONS AND OUR SO CALLED TEACHERS CAN NOT CLEAR THE EXAMS. Do they have the right to be in the teacher’s seat? What the hell we are going to achieve if quality people remain aside from education? With such foolish decisions, our country is never going to attain real heights in education and research.
How can UGC compare a degree like M.Phil or even Ph.D. with the NET exam which is a Nationwide exam? In Ph.D. or M. Phil. the people are working with a specific goal and highly specialized fields whereas in NET/SET exams, the overall AWARENESS of the subject is tested and PEOPLE CALLING THEMSELVES TEACHERS CAN NOT QUALIFY THE TESTS!!!!!

SHAME ON YOU PEOPLE!!!!!!!!!!! SHAME SHAME SHAME SHAME SHAME !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Dr Anoop kumar tiwari
14 Dec 2010

Dear Sir,

I’m a new faculty member at NIT Raipur .I want to attend the program on teaching skills of faculty. Can I attend?
Regards
Dr Anoop kumar Tiwari

Amar kumar
14 Dec 2010

Why AcSIR enrolling their own project assistents for PhD. As per govt. “This is open for all”

Ramesh
14 Dec 2010

Dress codes are in force in other states(some under the rule of “Progressive” parties-Cong I is in the ruling coalition of one of them – if NSUI is not protesting in that state, why in MP alone?

Afrin
14 Dec 2010

is it only for B-school Students or other MBA students can also attend

P.Vinayaga Murthy
14 Dec 2010

Dear Sir,

I am a professor in Social science. I strongly feel that not only teachers of technical education but also teachers of arts & sciences need skills in teaching. If you extend your programme to us also, we will be greatful and i too interested to attend the course.
Yours,
P.Vinayaga Murthy,
Tirupati.

Dadasaheb Wagh
14 Dec 2010

UGC has taken very good decision for M.Phil holders.

Kannan
14 Dec 2010

Congratulations & Best Wishes to Prof. Rameshan!

vikram
14 Dec 2010

delhi & madras high court decisions are against m. phil holders. what is latest status on the issue?

Prashant
14 Dec 2010

this is very good news for us. but there is issues for ugc that is approved by commission

Vikram
14 Dec 2010

delhi & madras high court decisions are against m. phil holders. what is latest status on the issue?

Dadasaheb wagh
14 Dec 2010

UGC has taken very good decision for M.Phil holders.

SANDEEP SHARMA
14 Dec 2010

OKAY, NO PROBLEM THAT M.PHIL HOLDERS ARE EXEMPTED FROM NET BUT ON THE BASIS OF EXEMPTION WHETHER THE NET QUALIFIED CANDIDATES WILL BE PREFERRED FOR THE POST OF LECTURER OR NOT ??????????????

Vikram
14 Dec 2010

what is the latest status. can hrd denied the order of court.

Vijaykumar
14 Dec 2010

This is really Nice and Intelligent decision taken by UGC to exempt M.Phil holders from NET/SET.In India many universities are good and recognized with best quality and performance and they are not sailing any academic degree.Those have passed NET/SET they have also passed P.G.from same universities Then how come they blame M.Phil/Ph.D holders?Hence stop jealous on research oriented society of our country and improve our qualification in research.

Vikram
14 Dec 2010

In a significant ruling that could affect lecturer aspirants across the country, the Madras high court on Monday held that a pass in the National Eligibility Test (NET) or the State-Level Eligibility Test ( SLET) will continue to be the mandatory qualification to apply for assistant professor posts in colleges.

The first bench comprising Chief Justice M Yusuf Eqbal and Justice TS Sivagnanam, dismissing a batch of writ petitions and appeals filed by candidates with only MPhil qualification who have been seeking either exemption or sufficient time to clear NET/SLET, said: “The regulation and the decision of the central government (insisting on the NET/SLET) cannot, at any stretch of imagination, be held to be illegal, arbitrary or whimsical. The decision is rational and based on public interest and also national policy to upgrade the standard of education in the country.”

The writ appeals were filed after a single judge dismissed the petitions against the central policy on April 22.

The petitioners had sought to restrain the University Grants Commission (UGC) and the Teachers’ Recruitment Board (TRB) from insisting on NET/SLET qualification for candidates who have passed MPhil prior to 1993 for appointment as assistant professors in Tamil Nadu Collegiate Educational Service. Noting that the UGC’s regulations notified in July 2009 did not exempt candidates who had obtained their MPhil degrees prior to December 31, 1993, the petitioners also wanted the regulations to be quashed.

Opposing the petitions, additional solicitor general of South India M Ravindran and senior central government standing counsel P Chandrasekaran, representing the Centre, submitted that there were more than 12,000 NET-qualified candidates waiting for employment. If the requests of the petitioners are accepted, it would mean compromising on quality of education and teaching standard in colleges.

P Wilson, additional advocate-general of Tamil Nadu, representing the TRB, said that if the state did not follow the UGC regulations the Centre would not extend grants. Referring to the UGC’s recent decision to exempt the candidates who obtained an MPhil degree on or before July 10, 2009 from clearing NET, he said such attempts have not been approved by the Centre. The HRD ministry too had earlier submitted that the UGC’s decision is clearly incongruous and hence not acceptable.

Concurring with the submissions, the judges said the HRD ministry formed an experts’ committee as it felt the need to upgrade the standard of teaching. After the Prof Mungerkar committee submitted its report, the government asked the UGC to frame guidelines. “But, the UGC, without considering the object and purpose of raising the standard of education, and without considering the global scenario, tried to give certain relaxation to the candidates for appearing in NET/SLET examination. In our opinion, the Central government has rightly refused to approve the decision of the UGC.”

The UGC had last year notified its new regulations on minimum qualifications for teaching faculty as per which a pass in the NET was mandatory for appointment as assistant professors. This regulation had invited strong protests from a cross-section of the academic community and also led to multiple litigations in various high courts.

Pratap Raychaudhuri
14 Dec 2010

It is difficult to understand why people with an M.Phil degree cannot clear an exam like Net. Does this speak about the quality of M. Phil degree that we are awarding?

jenny
14 Dec 2010

UGC will always stress on ‘NET pass’ as mandatory as this is a good source of income twice a year.If an application causes 500 rupees and nearly 1.5 lakhs candidates appear for this exam, that makes up a total of 75000000 rupees and that too twice a year ie.,150000000 RS.Now do you think UGC will compromise ?

And I would please suggest the authorities to pass the rule that ”existing lecturers” working in colleges right now,too be asked to clear NET in a given time span, failing which they be expelled from their professorship.

Is it only mandatory for freshers to be intellectual and those inside be otherwise? i know of many of them who joined various colleges with only Mphil a couple of years back when the rule was relaxed. And those lecturers who are working now…do you think they will clear NET given a rule ? NEVER.

and what about those ENGINEERS working in engineering colleges with only an ME or MTech Degree …sad to say there are even BE holders teaching ? Why does’nt AICTE Expel all those people without PhD even?

And the TamilNadu Govt has no rights to talk about SET exams, as this has not been conducted for the past 2 years now…especially for lifesciences.

If the government has no belief in MPhil and PhDs it is better they stop all these courses and stop irritating the society. I suppose there is no point in people going for higher studies or research when a postgraduation with NET IS ENOUGH TO TEACH even MPHIL STUDENTS IN A COLLEGE ?

IMAGINE A FRESH ” MSC graduate WITH NET ” teaching MPHIL students in a college ? THIS IS THE GREATEST HEIGHT OF STUPIDITY !!!

Anyway, this rule cannot be accepted as righteous or as keeping the standards but rather as a biased judgement from the side of hippocratic authorities whose traditional ideas dont permit to compromise with the needs of todays society.

K SENTHIL KANNAN
14 Dec 2010

IT IS A BAD MOVE AND NOT A REPRESENTATION OF QUALIFIED AND EFFICIENT CANDIDATES REPRESENTATION

Mukesh
14 Dec 2010

It is a foolish decision of UGC to implement the regulation of 2009 which is binding to the people who have already Completed Ph.D. before july 2009. Such a decision is a foolish and unlawful. What is the fault of a students who have completed the degree according to the norms of a university. If it is so, who should be punished for spoiling the four to five years of a student? Who is responsible for that? UGC? University or MHRD???????

It needs to be clarified by the UGC/MHRD that is it applicable for the students who have already completed or awarded Ph.D. Degree before july 2009.

UGC should not dance always? UGC?MHRD should make it mandatory for all the states to conduct SET/SLET examination. If NET/SET is compulsory then MHRD should make it mandatory for the people who are appointed as Assistant Professor through state PSC.

sukhi
14 Dec 2010

It does not look like good or bad decision. This judgement gives little hope to Non-NET qualified candidates but the same time you can see the splitting decision of UGC and MHRD. There is serious problem with decision making body because I hope they have their own candidates and they are working some of the colleges/Universities and they want to promote them…

UGC is not looking like healthy academic body.
Sukhi

Rajeev
14 Dec 2010

It is good decision by UGC. If peon, clerk selection is done by examination then why there is not for lecturers. Transparency in selection should also be made and deserving candidates should be selected as on most of the places source, money etc prevails over the qualifications.

Rajeshwari
14 Dec 2010

I think ugc and hrd are playing with the students who have completed their mphil and served 7 to 13 years in ug colleges. What about their future? What decision has taken the hrd regarding mphil cutoff date please any one can inform?

N ramesh
14 Dec 2010

This decision comes out after the students knock the door of the court.UGC has taken the decision to exempt the M.Phil / Ph.D Students who have cleared the M.Phil examination on or before 10July2009.Dr. Mungekar has also put the qualification for lecturer / Assistant Professor as net/set, or M.Phil or Ph.D in his interim report of qualification which was submitted to UGC. it was correct because there were no barriers of dates to qualifications. It is injustice to the candidates who clears the qualification after the cut off date because education is a continuous process.

Jerin jose
14 Dec 2010

I am very happy to hear the news. Because I am working as a Physical Director in temporary basis for a long preiod. Eventhogh my M.Phil. batchmates in different displines got permanent appointments in Govt. as well as Aided Colleges, but I didn’t. So this move from U.G.C. will support me a lot for my carrier.

Yogesh Wagh
14 Dec 2010

This is coolest news of this year!

thanks UGC guys !

pranjal
14 Dec 2010

It is not at all a welcome move by UGC. Such decision can’t improve the quality of Indian higher education.

DR.T.E.PARTHASARATHY
14 Dec 2010

Yesterday 10 MHRD took a different stand before HON.COURT at Chennai:no relaxation fromset/net.why?

G.Muralidharan
14 Dec 2010

This is happiest news for me because i am a Mphil holder working as a guest lecturer for the past five years.since today several phd holders working in colleges can’t able to handle the classes fluently.I coudnt understand why the Hrd is fixing the phd qualification for Lecturers.

ravi m n
14 Dec 2010

ITS REALLY ZILLION DECISION TAKEN BY UGC. IT GIVES REBIRTH TO ALL MPHIL HOLDERS. THANKS TO ALL COURTS, COMMISSION MEMBERS AND THOSE WHO ARE THE PART OF THIS DECISION.

Pinki insan
14 Dec 2010

Its a fantabulous news of this year. Its really a wonderful decision for which we were waiting for such a long time. Thank to Almighty. I also want to say that the HPSC posts of lecturers recently issued should be reissued so that we can also fill form for these posts.

surya
14 Dec 2010

Hi, No problem if you finished M.Phil before 2006-2007.But after…..? Plz let me know what was Madras High court order.Surya

Chandrakantha Shenoy
14 Dec 2010

This is really a good decision. All the M.Phil and P.Hd holders whole heartedly welcome this decision. It has given life to all M.Phil degree holders.
Thanking you.

Dr.PONMURALI
14 Dec 2010

Before 1993 M.Phil candidates should be permitted to appear for govt posts. such way in TRB of Tamilnadu Ph.D holders should be given additional marks

Sukhjit kaur
14 Dec 2010

What is this non-sense??? Why are the decisions changing so frequently?? Whatever UGC wants to decide, take the decision once..

Chandankumar
14 Dec 2010

i would like to know whether the decission taken by UGC on 9th november 2010, to give exemption for all mphil candidates who are awareded mphil degree on or before 10,july 2009 is applicable for the candidates who obtained the mphil degree form open universities?

Prof Koshy ninan
14 Dec 2010

It is s a welcome move that the ministry has intervened at the correct time. Let UGC make wise decisions only

Ma
14 Dec 2010

What is the rationale behind the cut off date ie. July 10, 2009? Are the students awarded the degree after this date less qualified? Or UGC will wait till someone is going to the High Court for that.

praveen
14 Dec 2010

can sombody tell me about those students who have enrolled themselves for M Phil in 2006 and passed their theory exam in 2007 but could submit their dissertation/viva after july 2009.Which date will be considered for exemption,,,,,,date of enrolement or date of getting certificate

Ganesh lekkala
14 Dec 2010

sir what about after 10 july who had awraded mphil candidates . is realy useless this certificate ? what about these awards is there any chance to go to court aganist this verdict ?

Koshy ninan
14 Dec 2010

Occasional relaxation to academic qualification is not in tune with quality improvement in higher education

Milind
14 Dec 2010

wht abt MBA lecturers they are not required any NET or Ph.D. Degree for this job. wht is correct info. reg. this

ranga rao
14 Dec 2010

this is very very good news for people who are working in private colleges, for low salaries by having M.Phil, degree. thank you very much for UGC

Vitthal Rahane
14 Dec 2010

Is there any difference in M. Phil or Ph. D. Degree obtained before and after July 2009 and December 2009. UGC is just playing with careers of these Degree holders. What is to be exempted.. Decide once.. and forget.

raj
14 Dec 2010

i wanna put some questions:

1.wt is the basic standard to define the quality of education?

2. is there any relevance of UGC?

3.why the academician is not willing to commence IES (INDIAN EDUCATIONAL SERVICES)?

4. why rules and regulations of UGC are changing so frequently?

In my view, the improvement in education can only be achieved through IES. each and every appointment of lectures and profs is based on jack. therefore there is an urgent need of an unified commission that should be governed by UPSC. further UGC should be scrapped.if we do nt be rational at this time, the whole education system of Bharat would collapse one day that is not too far.
JAI HIND!! JAI BHARAT!!

Vivek chandra mishra
14 Dec 2010

hi!
what about the M.Phil degree from an open university? Specially from The Global Open University of Nagaland. Is that also exempted from Net exam?

srinivas
14 Dec 2010

very sad. UGC IS WORSE THAN EUNUCH. DOES IT HAVE ANY DEFINED POLICY OR IT WORKS AS PER WHIMS OF FEW LOT HAVING PERSONALISED LINKAGES. LET IT SPELL THAT THREE YEARS AFTER HAVING PASSED M PHIL AND ONE YEAR AFTER PH.D THERE WILL NOT BE ANY NEED FOR NET, MANY OF US WILL STOP PREPARING FOR NET AND JOIN BANDWAGON OF MPHIL/PHD STUDENTS WITH VINTAGE LECTURERS OF UNIVERSITIES TO COMPLETE AND STAY AWAY FROM TENSION ON ACCOUNT OF NET REQUIRMENT. VERY BAD NEWS FOR ENLIGHTENED LOT BUT GOOD FOR MANY WHO ARE REQUIRED BY EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS HAVING PATRONAGE OF CORRUPT ADMINISTRATORS AND POLITICIANS. HOPE OUR HRD MINISTER SRI KAPIL JI WOULD GIVE A THOUGHT SERIOUSLY.

REGARDS TO ALL WHO ARE HURT, WITH MALICETOWARDS NONE.

Ram laxaman
14 Dec 2010

Dr. M.P. Pandey Hon’ble Vice chancellor, Indira Gandhi Krishi Vishwavidayalay (State Agricultural University,), Raipur (Chhattisgarh) has denied this judgement for please give the suggestion to apply this amendment for the benefit of affected employees of our university

Dipak biswas
14 Dec 2010

Sir, I completed M.phil degree from Annamalai Univ. thro. distance education on 4th April,2009. Whether this degree will be valid in the eye of UGC after the passing of Madras high court order?

Ramesh
14 Dec 2010

Its very good news to all MPHIL studets we are studed 2 years at centrl universities so UGC recognised till today so we onec again congratulaton taken decision thank you very mauch plsent this new ugc regulatio to all state governament then we will get some benifits now one notification is going on andhra pradesh degree colege lectures so besed on this regulation we will eligible sir pl my humble request to ugc as early as posible give orders to all state governments. thank you very much taking good decision.
Ramesh pondicherry university

Harish
14 Dec 2010

I came to know that UGC HRD not accepted the UGC 472nd meeting decissions ie MPhil degree not considered for NET exemption

avinash
14 Dec 2010

can sombody tell me about those students who have enrolled themselves for M Phil in 2008 and passed their theory exam /dissertation/viva after july 2009.Which date will be considered for exemption,date of enrolement or date of getting certificate

pls tell me

Pramod
14 Dec 2010

Thanks to honorable High Court, its a right verdict came at the right time. Actually there is no agency to test the knowledge of PhD/MPhil or NET/SET qualified teachers. If Government wants to make NET/SET mandatory, then why did they exempt PhD and MPhil passed candidates time to time? In my opinion the UGC is not run well nowadays, because every year there is a new amendment about the appointment of lecturers, which is beyond our comprehension. Due to the 3rd amendment pub. by UGC in July 2009, MPhil holders before 10th July 2009 stood disqualified, which is an injustice done by UGC in my opinion. Because to get an MPhil degree requires much efforts.If UGC and HRD think that few students have done some wrong things in getting MPhil degree then search and disqualify them, but don’t punish innocent and honest students. I may only hope that HRD and UGC will take right decision at least this time and exempt those candidates from the NET exam, who have passed MPhil before June 2009, because it is the question of the future of thousands of MPhil holders in various subjects across the nation.

giri
14 Dec 2010

this is very very bad move frm ugc i think ugc is dancing to the tune some influencial people. on one side ugc says that it is trying to ensure quality in higher education and on other side it is making such foolish descisions. do you think that quality can be maintained by the M.Phil certificate purchased people?. eve if it is a regular M. Phil of one year or One and half year coourse can it be compared with the Ph.D ?. ugcs` descion taken in the year 2006 to exempt net was itself a foolish descision, due to which so many teaching post were filled with lot of corruption in karnataka. many of the Net qualified candidates were left behind and only M.Phl holders got the Job, that too M.Phil certificates were brought within month (purchased). i feel sorry and would like to say that ugc has gone mad !!!

Nchoudhury
14 Dec 2010

The regulation of exemption of Net/Slet for who have awarded MPhil degree on or before 10th July 2009 as per verdict of Chennai High Court, Is there any notice/ regulation listed on the the UGC website http://www.ugc.ac.in. by UGC.If yes it will be very helpful if the link is posted in the forum and my email.

Madhuri
14 Dec 2010

i will b happy with the decision. it should b applied to all universities of india.Thsi is a good judgement by the court i appreciate it. Those who criticise it they dont know importance of the M.Phil. This is a academic job there need experience of research . If UGC not exempted M.Phil what is the importance of M.Phil. Why we do M.Phil . Just clear master degree and not carry on further study just complete UGC NET. Many guys working in university of delhi only cleared master degree. once again thanks for UGC. Actually, UGC save future of research. otherwise no use of Mphil.

littafleix
14 Dec 2010

THANKS TO UGC FOR THOSE WHO FIGHT FOR THEIR RIGHTS WITH M.Phil.,

Shinde pv
14 Dec 2010

We Know Dr. Thorat is always with us but what about the Ministry of H.R.

Sudeep sharma
14 Dec 2010

it is a welcome decision.it is justice to thousands of Ph.D. & M Phil. holders who have earned their deegre through years of dedication & hard work.this decision will also inspire youths to join research work.

gladys
14 Dec 2010

I have received my M.Phil in August 2009. Just one month I have fallen back.Why only 10 July 2009? This can’t be changed? Please helpo us

Ranjan
14 Dec 2010

The decision is fine. But how to get the circular at an earliest so that before the norm is again change someone can get employed. Is there is any link to get the circular over net. Kindly infrom.

gourav
14 Dec 2010

Thsi is a good judgement by the court i appreciate it. Those who criticise it they dont know importance of the M.Phil. Many guys working as permanent faculty member in delhi university just M.A and Net . Anyone define me only M.A can teach B.A level? This is a academic job there need experience of research . If UGC not exempted M.Phil what is the importance of M.Phil. Why we do M.Phil . Just clear master degree and not carry on further study just complete UGC NET. Many guys working in university of delhi only cleared master degree. once again thanks for UGC. Actually, UGC save future of research. otherwise no use of Mphil.

john sameul
14 Dec 2010

The UGC decision is not correct. Definitely the M Phil degrees are sold like hotcakes. If you have 10,000 rupees you will be awarded the M Phil thesis and in some cases the thesis data were manipulated without any real field work. This is case of the MPhil degree.But qualifying the NET is not like that at least they are reviewing the relevant subject. (I hope the loop holes and back door entries are very very minimum for NET when compared with obtaining MPhil degree). In this regard UGC must roll back to maintain the standard.And HRD should intervene.

Pradip
14 Dec 2010

” Der se aaye par durust aaye "

maina
14 Dec 2010

thanks ugc.but after this announcement how will be the advertisements??????????is it NET/SLET/M.PHIL/PH.D?

mudasir
14 Dec 2010

UGC should take a final decision for the minimum qualifiaction separately for Colleges and universities and all Ph.D. Scholars who have been registered by 2010 should be exempted from NET

Rifat
14 Dec 2010

It is for the first When UGC has taken M.Phil degree into consideration.I welcome the UGC chairman on this behalf. However Ph.D. scholars who have been registered since long and their degrees are still hanging also deserve the same

Lakhya Pratim
14 Dec 2010

Decision of UGC is right. The new decision of UGC solved many problems of M. Phil. candidates. Bcoz, the M. Phil. candidates obtain their Degree after one year hard work in university. The degree of M. Phil. is not like easy money that anybody wants in anytime and they get according to their wish. It is done after hard work, submission of Dissertation, collection of data both Primary & Secondary. That is why, the UGC take their decision in right time. It is true that the NET exam cannot find a merit student only with a single day long exam. It is universal true. Thank you UGC.

Yrvs
14 Dec 2010

Sir/Madam,
Please clarify about those students who have enrolled themselves for M Phil in 2006 and passed their theory exam in 2008 but could submit their dissertation/viva after july 2009.Which date will be considered for exemption?
Date of enrolement or date of getting certificate

OP swami
14 Dec 2010

this is not a good news for the candidate who has NET/SLAT crackers.due to this news no difference occur between net holder&m.phil. holder. because more than75% people m.phil. completed via open university,the college where attendence is not compulsory,completed thesis by illegal manner(by theft,by giving money)which is very normal think in private college.thhs NET/SLET must be minimum requirment for lecturer/assistant prof.

thanks
Mr.O.P.Swami’KSHITIZ’
M.Sc.,NET(2 times in physical sc.),SLET

Pknath
14 Dec 2010

IT NEVER BE WORST DECISION. SEE THE TIMING OF THE REGULATION. WHATEVER REGULATION IS ENFORCING THE STUDENTS WHO ARE STUDYING IN PREVIOUS REGULATION CAN NOT NEGLECT. FOR THE M.PHIL OR PH.D. LIQUIDITY UGC IS RESPOSIBLE, NEITHER UNIVERSITY NOR STUDENTS ARE RESPONSIBLE. THE STUDENTS WHO ARE DOING SINCERELY PH.D OR M.PHIL. THEY CAN NOT BE DEPRIVED FROM ANY BINDING NEW REGULATION.

P Vivek
14 Dec 2010

Decision of UGC is right. The new decision of UGC solved many problems of M. Phil. candidates. Because,the M. Phil. candidates obtain their Degree after one year hard work in university. It is done after hard work, submission of Dissertation, collection of data both Primary & Secondary. That is why, the UGC take their decision in right time. It is true that the NET exam cannot find a merit student only with a single day long exam. It is universal true. Thanks for UGC. similarly ugc should take strong and emergency decision about Self financing colleges. Thanks to Almighty..

giri
14 Dec 2010

this is very very bad move frm ugc i think ugc is dancing to the tune some influencial people. on one side ugc says that it is trying to ensure quality in higher education and on other side it is making such foolish descisions. do you think that quality can be maintained by the M.Phil certificate purchased people?. eve if it is a regular M. Phil of one year or One and half year coourse can it be compared with the Ph.D ?. ugcs` descion taken in the year 2006 to exempt net was itself a foolish descision, due to which so many teaching post were filled with lot of corruption in karnataka. many of the Net qualified candidates were left behind and only M.Phl holders got the Job, that too M.Phil certificates were brought within month (purchased). i feel sorry and would like to say that ugc has gone mad !!!

Kkp
14 Dec 2010

Ofcourse the decision of UGC is right. But what about others who enrolled for MPhil in 2007, completed first part and could not able to complete dissertation part becouse of lagging attitude of guides/ teachers. They are loosers without having any mistakes of their own. My opinion is M.phil should be made eqvelent to NET and some should have some control on universities to issue the degree. Otherwise, a groups of candidate should go to court frequently to get the exemption…which is not good practice

Omer
14 Dec 2010

we r very happy because thousands of mphil candidates life will shine in the society, family & future