Reduce outside control on Central institutions: HRD panel

Create: 03/21/2011 - 18:13

The HRD panel headed by NR Madhav Menon which is working on "Evolve a Comprehensive Policy for Autonomy of Central Educational Institutions" has suggested that the concept of office of the visitor in central universities should be removed. At present, the President is the visitor to all central universities. The committee has recommended that the powers of the visitor be transferred to the Chancellor. The powers of the visitor include appointing the vice-chancellor, certain members of the court, executive council, finance committee, selection committees.

The visitor also has the power to order enquiries and institute inspections, give or withhold assent to the statutes, arbitrate disputes between selection committees and executive councils on the appointment of teachers and annul any proceeding of the universities which is not in conformity with the laws and regulations.

The committee has also pointed out that instead of appointing civil service officials to university positions a pool of education-administrators with expertise in managing educational and research institutions should be created that will handle the administrative offices in the universities. It has also recommended establishing an office of ombudsman in each central university to intervene in crisis situations.

"There is a need to free universities and central educational institutions from extensive control from outside for which statutes establishing them have to be revisited. Clauses subversive to institutional autonomy need to be repealed or modified to enable institutions to function with freedom and accountability.
In this process, it is desirable to ensure that the membership of academic bodies is strictly restricted to eminent academicians and independent experts," the committee states in its report to human resource development minister Kapil Sibal. The committee has also pitched for setting up of Central Universities Council, on lines of the IIT Council.

Barring the 14 universities set up under the Central Universities Act, 2009, each of the remaining central universities has been set up under separate Acts of Parliament. While there are historical reasons for this, the committee is of the view that it is now time to bring in some uniformity in the legal framework and subsume all these separate legislations into one.

On the matter of autonomy in academic issues, the committee suggested that all central universities adopt a system of choice-based credit courses along with semester system. This would help promote flexibility in the academic structure and promote students mobility.

The committee has suggested switching over to complete internal evaluation of students with faculty members having full autonomy in evaluation matters. In the transition period, it has suggested a mix of internal and external evaluation. The committee has said all faculty members shall be subjected to a review once every five years by a review committee appointed by the executive council.

The committee has recommended that universities should be free to decide fees, scholarships and recoveries. All this will have to be in line with the broad policy guidelines of the government.It has also suggested that all central universities undergo a comprehensive review of their functioning once every 10 years by an external agency.

The other members of the committee are Seyed E Hasnain, Pankaj Chandra, MS Ananth, Mihir Choudhary and Ved Prakash.

[Source: Economic  Times]


Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on

I hope the recommendations will see the light of the day, specifically the issues concerning the autonomy and freedom at different levels. Many a times, we ponder upon the issue why we do not have noble laureates from among the academicians/ scientists working under Indian conditions, I think it matters a lot under what conditions one is working. Many a times, it has been observed that the people involved in research in higher education institutions have to devote more time in getting the files cleared, following various en-lengthened procedures for procurement etc than the time spent on the actual research. More so, at times it is considered a personal affair. There is a strong need to evolve a mechanism to free the Institutions of higher education and research from the shackles the red tapism and bureaucracy.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on

Sam, I fully agree with your concerns that we should be doing not debating on the issues concerning higher education in the country but 'Babus' will not like to lose control on the system. They want you to discuss the same issues again and again, probably to prove NKC wrong. We in universities answer more queries to Babus than to students. You have yourself been through this in the past so do not be anguished, things are moving, although slowly but surely in the desired direction.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on

I agree with the views expressed by Prof. Madhav Menon. reduction of external control over the central institutions will reduce the bureaucratic hurdles and give more autonomy to these institutions.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on

IAS people should not be appointed as VC or CEOs of central or state universities.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on

I would like congratulate Professors Madhav Menon, Seyed E Hasnain, Pankaj Chandra, MS Ananth, Mihir Choudhary and Ved Prakash for their courageous and thoughtful recommendations. I welcome their proposal of giving autonomy to the central universities. This will be the right direction. I also appreciate the evaluation of teachers every 5 years. My congratulations again.

Prof Ranjan Chakrabarti
Jadavpur University

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on

The guidelines should be implemented on priority, it is well known that organizing a conference in the present university setup is less hectic than clearing the bills. Whereas the same is done very fast in research institutions.

About Author

India Education Review
India Education Review is a platform that aims to provide information and resources to senior educators nationwide. Carrying news, interviews, guest articles, case studies, information on training and developmental programs, scholarships and jobs, India Education Review is the platform of choice for the educator community in India today